Immigration Law
Non Immigrant Visa
NIV Visas Overview/Introduction
Non-immigrant visas are for a specific purpose and a specific time. They allow the foreign national to present himself to US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) at the Port of Entry (POE) so that the CBP officer can allow them to enter for a specific time as per the visa stamped in foreign national’s passport.
Non-Immigrant Intent
One requirement of all non-immigrant visas is that the petitioner have and demonstrate non-immigrant intent. Non-immigrant intent is the intent of the foreign national to return to their home country following the expiration of the period of stay for which the foreign national was admitted. This is unless the foreign national obtains permission to stay in the United States permanently and adjust status to that of a Lawful Permanent Resident (LPR) through marriage or employment or “other reliefs.”
Temporary Visas
B-1- NIV Visa: Temporary Business Visitor
The period of stay is 1 to 6 months; Six months is the maximum. An extension is possible: Up to 6 months; The maximum total amount of time permitted in B-1 status on any one trip is generally 1 year.
Productive work is disallowed. This includes activities by a B1 visa holder that would be performed by a US worker and would result on gain for a US employer. Allowed activities include:
- Consulting with business associates
- Traveling for a scientific, educational, professional or business convention, or a conference on specific dates
- Settling an estate
- Negotiating a contract
- Participating in short-term training
- Looking at investment opportunities – later we will cover E-2 or EB-5 so remember this category
B-1 vs. Visa Waiver Program Advantage
The B1 has a longer stay period than the Visa Waiver program. Furthermore, a B1 visa holder can change status to another NIV category while a member of the Visa Waiver program cannot do the same.
B-1 in Lieu of H-1B
A U.S. employer can bring a foreign employee/affiliate to the U.S. for a short-term commitment. This will directly benefit from the overseas employer.
Requirements for B1 in Lieu of H1B:
- The visa holder should be an employee of a foreign subsidiary;
- The Employee should have the US equivalent of a bachelor’s degree;
- The kind of work involved should fall under the ‘specialty’ occupation, meaning that it requires theoretical and practical application of a body of highly specialized knowledge;
- The work should be performed within a short duration;
- The employee should maintain permanent employment with the foreign employer.
B2- Tourism or Family Visit Visa
B-2 visa status is granted to aliens traveling to the US as tourists or to visit family or friends. The period of stay is 1 to 6 months; six months is the maximum. An extension of up to 6 months is possible. The maximum total amount of time permitted in B-1 status on any one trip is generally 1 year.
The following activities are allowed:
- Medical Reasons: Aliens coming to the US to receive medical treatment are eligible for B-2 visa status.
- Participation in Social Events: Aliens may travel to the United States under B-2 visa status to participate in conventions, conferences, or convocations of fraternal, social, or service organizations.
- Armed Forces Dependents: B-2 visa status can be granted to dependents of an alien member of any branch of the US Armed Forces temporarily assigned for duty in the United States.
- Dependents of Crewmen: B-2 visa status can be granted to alien dependents of D visa crewmen who are coming to the US for the sole purpose of accompanying the principal D visa holder.
- Aliens Attending a Short Course of Study: Aliens coming to the US primarily for tourism are also allowed to partake in a short course of study.
- Amateur Entertainers and Athletes: An amateur is by definition not a professional in their activity. Therefore, an amateur is someone who normally performs the activity without payment. An amateur (or group of amateurs), who will not be paid for any performances they make, may perform in the US for social/charitable reasons or as a competitor in a talent show, contest, or athletic event under B-2 visa status.
Study Visas: F1 & M1- Academic and Vocational School
The F1 and M1 provide student and vocational school visas, respectively. They require:
- Admission to an educational institution before you can submit a visa application (this school must be on the list of schools provided by the Student Exchange Visitor Program (SEVP), which also manages the Student Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS), which is a database used to track student information, such as enrollment, graduation, changes to programs, and maintenance of required course load).
- Proof of relevant educational qualifications
- A course load of a minimum of 12 credit hours
- Proof of sufficient funds for the stay (tuition, room and board)
- Participants must possess nonimmigrant intent (i.e. the intention to depart the US at the conclusion of their course of study).
- Form 1-20 Certificate of Eligibility of Nonimmigrant Student Status, obtained from their chosen school
- Consular processing of Form DS-160 Online Nonimmigrant Visa Application
- Proof of payment of visa application fee
Employment
Unlike the visitor visa classification, which strictly forbids employment, some students are able to work. There are several types of employment:
On-campus: this allows for 20 hours weekly, except during periods without study, in which case 40 hours are allowed. No special permit is required.
Off-campus: Available only after the first year is completed and is based on demonstration of severe economic necessity. This requires application for and Employment Authorization Document (EAD- I-765). This work does not count against the Optional Practical Training Period.
Post Completion Optional Practical Training (OPT): Available after graduate with approval of both Congress and Executive branch. This is viewed as a key feature of the educational process.
Curricular Practical Training (CPT): Training closely associated with one’s chosen course of study. Consists of industry internship. An EAD is not necessary. All one has to do is get a suitable job and have the Designate School Official (DSO) annotate the Form I-20, Certificate of Eligibility for Nonimmigrant Student status. If one exceeds 364 days of CPT employment, s/he cannot also receive Optional Practical Training.
Spouses and Dependents
Spouses and children can get F-2 and M-2 visas by applying, using a SEVIS Form I-20, Certificate of Eligibility for Nonimmigrant Student Status, listing her or him as a dependent. The dependent must establish that the principal foreign national is in valid student status, using a current copy of the Form I-20, along with proof of the familial relationship. They may not work. They can undertake a less than full-time course of study, or full time (if they are minor children). If the spouse (or a minor child) wants to engage in a full-time course of study, they must apply for their own F-1 visa.
Work Visas
E-2 Non-Immigrant Investor
E-2 8 INA 101(a)(15)(E); 8 C.F.R. §214.2(e)
The E-2 nonimmigrant classification allows a foreign national of a treaty country (a country with which the United States maintains a treaty of commerce and navigation) to be admitted to the United States when investing a substantial amount of capital in a U.S. business.
https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/us-visas/visa-information-resources/fees/treaty.html
This visa allows non-immigrant investors to live and work in the U.S. based on a qualifying Investment. It requires an E-2 treaty between U.S. and the home country, allowing investors or their managers or essential employees to work in the U.S.
- The investor or employee must be a citizen of a country with an E-2 Treaty.
- U.S. company must be at least 50% owned by foreign nationals or company with nationality from the treaty country. Co-owners who are LPR’s, or US citizens with dual nationality don’t count towards the 50%.
- The investment must be substantial — $150K minimum but varies based on the needs of the company.
- The U.S. business must be up and running or close to opening its doors.
- The U.S. business must show a business plan to hire U.S. workers over time. No quota on the number of U.S. workers is required.
- A visa from the U.S. Consulate is usually for 3 to 5 years, based on reciprocity agreement.
- US Custom Border Protection (CBP) gives an I-94 at port of entry for 2 years at a time. There are no quotas and no limit on renewals.
- An E-2 visa spouse can apply for an Employee Authorization Document (EAD).
You can morph an E-2 into an EB-5 if, over time, you have a cumulative investment of $1M and 10 new full-time jobs. Or you can do it with $500K/10 new full-time jobs, if the job creating enterprise is in a Targeted Employment Area.
L-1 Intra-Company Transferee (L-1A Intracompany Transferee Executive or Manager) L-1B: Intracompany Transferee Specialized Knowledge)
An L-1 visa is used to transfer a key employee from the overseas company to a U.S. parent, subsidiary, or affiliate.
- An L-1A visa is for an executive or high-level manager – 7 years maximum for L-1A. An L-1B visa is for a specialized knowledge worker whose skills and knowledge about company operations cannot be easily found in the U.S. – 5 years maximum for an L-1B.
- For both the L-1A and L-1B visas, the foreign national must have worked for overseas affiliate for at least 1 year during the last 3 years
- The foreign national must show that the foreign company owns at least 51% of the U.S. company or vice versa or that a common owner controls both. Control is key.
- An L-2 spouse can apply for an EAD.
- A foreign national with an L-1A visa can apply for I-140 EB-1 multinational manager after one year, if strong merits present. Then they can file for an Adjustment of Status. Concurrent filing is not recommended.
Business Relationship
For purposes of L classification, ownership and control are the factors for establishing a qualifying relationship between business entities. The United States and foreign businesses must be legal entities.
In the United States, a business is usually in the form of a corporation, partnership, or a proprietorship.
- Ownership. Ownership means the legal right of possession with full power and authority to control.
- Control. Control means the right and authority to direct the management and operations of the business entity.
Qualifying Organizations For an L-1 Visa
The petitioner is required to identify each of the qualifying organizations as one of the following business entities:
(A) Parent. Any business entity which has subsidiaries is a parent. However, a subsidiary may own other subsidiaries and also be a parent, even though it has an ultimate parent.
(B) Branch. An office or operating division of the same employer which is merely housed in a different location and is not established as a separate business entity is considered a branch.
(C) Subsidiaries. The Service recognizes only three situations to constitute a subsidiary relationship:
(1) Where a parent directly or indirectly owns more than half of the entity and has control;
(2) Where a parent directly or indirectly owns 50% of a 50-50 joint venture and has equal control and veto power. The 50-50 joint venture can be owned and controlled by only two legal entities. All other combinations of a joint venture are not qualifying as a subsidiary;
(3) Where a parent directly or indirectly owns less than half of the entity, but has control because the other stock is widely dispersed among minor shareholders. This can happen, for example, when an individual or company acquires sufficient shares of a publicly-held company to be able to nominate and elect the board of directors.
(D) Affiliate. Subsidiaries are affiliates of each other. The affiliate relationship is due to the ownership and control of both subsidiaries by the same legal entity. Affiliation also exists between legal entities where an identical group of individuals own and control both businesses in basically the same proportions or percentages. Associations between companies based on factors such as ownership of a small amount of stock in another company, exchange of products or services, licensing or franchising agreements, membership on boards of directors, or the formation of consortiums or cartels do not create affiliate relationships between the entities for L purposes.
L-1 Intra-Company Transferee (L-1A Intracompany Transferee Executive or Manager)
General Qualifications of the Employer and Employee
To qualify for L-1 classification in this category, the employer must:
- Have a qualifying relationship with a foreign company (parent company, branch, subsidiary, or affiliate, collectively referred to as qualifying organizations); and
- Currently be, or will be, doing business as an employer in the United States and in at least one other country directly or through a qualifying organization for the duration of the beneficiary’s stay in the United States as an L-1. While the business must be viable, there is no requirement that it be engaged in international trade.
- Doing business means the regular, systematic, and continuous provision of goods and/or services by a qualifying organization and does not include the mere presence of an agent or office of the qualifying organization in the United States and abroad.
To qualify for an L-1 the named employee must also:
- have been working for a qualifying organization abroad for one continuous year within the three years immediately preceding his or her admission to the United States; and
- be seeking to enter the United States to provide service in an executive or managerial capacity for a branch of the same employer or one of its qualifying organizations.
Executive capacity generally refers to the employee’s ability to make decisions of wide latitude without much oversight.
Managerial capacity generally refers to the ability of the employee to supervise and control the work of professional employees and to manage the organization, or a department, subdivision, function, or component of the organization. It may also refer to the employee’s ability to manage an essential function of the organization at a high level, without direct supervision of others. See section 101(a)(44) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, as amended, and 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii) for complete definitions.
Period of Stay for an L-1A Classification
- Qualified employees entering the United States to establish a new office will be allowed a maximum initial stay of one year.
- All other qualified employees will be allowed a maximum initial stay of three years.
- For all L-1A employees, requests for extension of stay may be granted in increments of up to an additional two years, until the employee has reached the maximum limit of seven years
L-1B: Intracompany Transferee–Specialized Knowledge
The L-1B classification is for specialized knowledge worker whose skills and knowledge about company operations cannot be easily found in the U.S. It has a maximum of 5 years.
Specialized knowledge refers either to special knowledge possessed by an individual of the petitioning organization’s product, service, research, equipment, techniques, management, or other interests and its application in international markets, or an advanced level of knowledge or expertise in the organization’s processes and procedures (See 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(D)).
L-1B
Blanket Petitions
Certain organizations may establish the required intracompany relationship in advance of filing individual L-1 petitions by filing a blanket petition. Eligibility for blanket L certification may be established if:
- The petitioner and each of the qualifying organizations are engaged in commercial trade or services;
- The petitioner has an office in the United States which has been doing business for one year or more;
- The petitioner has three or more domestic and foreign branches, subsidiaries, and affiliates; and
- The petitioner along with the other qualifying organizations, collectively, must meet one of the following criteria:
o Have obtained at least 10 L-1 approvals during the previous 12-month period;
o Have U.S. subsidiaries or affiliates with combined annual sales of at least $25 million; or
o Have a U.S. work force of at least 1,000 employees.
- In order to qualify under the blanket petitioning process, the employee having specialized knowledge must also be a professional. See 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(E).
Period of Stay L-1B
Qualified employees entering the United States to establish a new office will be allowed a maximum initial stay of one year. All other qualified employees will be allowed a maximum initial stay of three years. For all L-1B employees, requests for extension of stay may be granted in increments of up to an additional two years, until the employee has reached the maximum limit of five years.
Family of L-1 Workers
The transferring employee may be accompanied or followed by his or her spouse and unmarried children who are under 21 years of age. Such family members may seek admission in L-2 nonimmigrant classification and, if approved, generally will be granted the same period of stay as the employee.
If these family members are already in the United States and seeking change of status to or extension of stay in L-2 classification, they may apply collectively, with fee, using Form I-539, Application to Extend/Change Status.
Spouses of L-1 workers may apply for work authorization by filing a Form I-765, Application for Employment Authorization with a fee. If approved, there is no specific restriction as to where the L-2 spouse may work.
Non-Immigrant Visas (NIV Visas)
WhendoinganNIVanalysis,beveryintunewiththeindividual’snationality.Somevisas are specifically tied to that: i.e. TN (Canada/Mexico), H-1B1 (Singapore/Chile), E-3 (Australia), E-2 (select countries), WT/WB (visa waiver),etc.
H-1B
This is a work authorization for certain college-degreed professionals, who must have college degree in a field related to the job offer. The position must include practical application of theoretical knowledge, also known as a “specialty occupation.” Common H-1B occupations include software developers, engineers, scientists, and financial analysts.
The employer:
- Must comply with Department of Labor (DOL) prevailing wage and pay same wages as U.S. workers receive or prevailing wage, whichever is higher. The “required wage” is the higher of the DOL prevailing wage or the actual wage paid to other U.S. workers doing the same job at the company.
- Mustplacepostingnoticeintwoplacesintheworkplaceforatleast10business days and file a Labor Condition Application (LCA) with DOL.
- Must maintain a public access file with the signed LCA and employer attestations of H-1B employer obligations in a file cabinet for the entire H-1B period and then for 1 additional year. The foreign national can only work for sponsoring employer, but can transfer employment with new H-1B visa petition.
The visa is good for 3 years and renewable for 3 additional years, for 6 years maximum.
The visa can extend beyond Year 6 if PERM labor cert pending more than 1 year (by the end of the 6-year H-1B clock) or has an approvedI-140.
AC-21 7-year extension – allows 1-year increments with PERM pending
AC-21 3-year extensions – if have approved PERM and approvedI-140
H-1B visa filings are subject to an annual quota of 85,000 visas, and the quota is quickly used up each year. U.S. Masters has slightly higher chance of getting into quota since 20,000 visas set aside for them and then will also be considered for regular H-1B quota of 65,000 as well.
Exemptions from quota include extensions with same company, the transfer to another company, and petitions filed by universities, nonprofit organizations affiliated with a university and non-profit research organizations.
For the first H-1B petition, file on April 1 for a start date of October1.
A company can sponsor one of its major shareholders for anH-1B if the company has a Board of Directors with authority to terminate the shareholder’s employment. They need to show bona fide employer – employee relationship.
H-1B Portability: For someone already in H-1B status, new employer can file petition and foreign national can start once an I-797 receipt notice has been received
If employer will move employee to another location outside the Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA), must file a new LCA and an amended petition.
H-4spouse cannot apply for an EAD if PA has approved an I-140 or if the PERM is pending more than a year.
If employer terminates the H-1B employment early, must offer return airfare back to their home country.
Layoff: H-1B has no official grace period once laid off, but USCIS uses 30-day unofficial grace period in granting Extension of Status (EOS)or else it will require consular processing.
H-1B1: H-1B1Singapore/Chile Free Trade Agreements
Singapore and Chile citizens can obtain work authorization with a U.S. company. The criteria are the same as for H-1B specialty occupation, college degree, etc. Admission is for 1 year at a time. There is no limit on renewals. The annual quota is never reached. Be careful to track LCA expiration, I-94 expiration, and visa expiration. Must have valid LCA to work. The H-1B1 spouse not eligible for a work permit.
E-3 Australians
This visa allows Australian citizens to obtain work authorization with a U.S. company. The criteria is the same as for H-1B specialty occupations, college degree, etc. Applicants apply at AMCON in Australia. Don’t file with USCIS as it has no Premium Processing and the 240-dayautomaticextensionofworkauthorizationdoesn’tapply. The visa is valid for 2 years. There is no limit on renewals. Be careful to track the Labor Condition Application (LCA) expiration, I-94 expiration, and visa expiration. Must have valid LCA to work. Spouse can obtain an EAD.
TN Visa: NAFTA Agreement with Canada and Mexico
The foreign national must have Canadian or Mexican passport. This is based on North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) between U.S., Canada and Mexico. The occupation must be on the NAFTA list. Common TN occupations include computer systems analysts, engineers and management consultants.
Canadians apply at U.S. border or can apply with USCIS and then show I-797 to CBP and receive I-94. Canadians receive three yearI-94.
Mexican citizens apply at AMCON in Mexico and receive 1 year visa. But CBP can issue 3-yearI-94. There is no limit on extensions. The TN spouse (TD) cannot work.
USICS I-9 Issues/Audit
Form I-9 was created as part of IRCA in1986. You can only give to an employee after they accept a job offer (otherwise potential discrimination issue). The employee must fill out and sign Section 1 on or before first day of hire. The employee must show the employer original work authorization documents. Employee gets to select work authorization documents – one from List A, or one from List B and List C.
The work authorization documents must be valid at the time of hire.
The employer fills out Section 2 and signs by Day 4 (best if Day 1). It must be same person who viewed original work authorization documents.
It is recommended that the employer photocopy work authorization documents and attach them to I- 9, but not required.
For USC’s and LPR’s, if documents subsequently expire, don’t need to re-verify as long as valid at time of hire.
For foreign nationals working with EAD or work visa, must re-verify on or before expiration date. Re-verify in Section 3.
Employer self-audit: Only the employee can amend Section 1. Only the employer can amend Section 2 or 3.
Technical errors – In audit, ICE will give employer opportunity to fix.
Substantive errors- typically $1,000 fine per I-9.
Statute of Limitations: employer liable for substantive errors for 5 years after correction.
Retention Period: Keep I-9’s throughout employment and for 3 years after termination.
Social Security mis-match letter from any government agency: Puts employer on constructive notice that employee may not be work-authorized. Employer should investigate and absent typo, send employee to SSA to get SSN verification letter.
InCalifornia,ifemployeewasworkingwithfalsedocumentsandhassincelegalized with EAD or LPR status, then employer cannot terminate for the prior mis-representation of name, SSN, and documents.
E-Verify
E-Verify: optional unless employer is a federal contractor or a State mandates it for employers within that State.
E-Verify is only for new hires, unless the employer is a federal contactor, then can useonexistingemployeesworkingonthecontract,orallexistingemployees.
Change of Status Vs. Consular Processing
Pros of Consular Processing
- Free to travel.
- Travel stamp in passport.
- Appear for the interview.
- Can speak with the adjudicating officer directly.
Cons
- No appeals process if denied.
- Some applicants/clients are intimated by interviews.
- If denied can only re-apply.
- Discretion- consular discretion is a huge factor. If they like the applicant, well and good- no appeal process for lack of favorable discretion.
Change of Status: Consider the Following Factors
New 90-Days Rule:
In September 2017, the U.S. Department of State (DOS) made a significant change to its Foreign Affairs Manual (FAM).
The purpose of the 90-day rule is to trigger, under specified circumstances, the presumption that an alien is inadmissible under section 212(a)(6)(C)(i) because of the alien’s “misrepresentation of a material fact” to obtain a benefit or visa under the INA.
The DOS states that the issue arises most often in cases where the nonimmigrant:
i. Applies for adjustment of status; or
ii. Fails to maintain nonimmigrant status (e.g., by engaging in unauthorized study or employment).
The new 90-day rule are binding on the USCIS. However, the USCIS takes the rule under advisement, and it has been referred to in a multitude of unpublished decisions of the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO).
A dual intent visa allows a foreigner to enter the United States as a nonimmigrant but retain the option to adjust status to a permanent resident at some point in the future. For example, a foreign national can who is fiancé to a USC uses a K-1 fiancé visa to enter the U.S. and marry a U.S. citizen. Likewise, employers will routinely sponsor a foreigner worker for an H-1B visa and later sponsor the nonimmigrant for a green card. The most common dual intent visas are:
– E-, H-, K-, L-, O-, and P-type visas are dual intent visas.
Visas for Artists, Athletes and Those Top of their Field
O-1A
This work authorization is for an individual who has demonstrated extraordinary ability in his/her field. They must be at the top of their field. It is valid for 3 years and renewable without limits. O-1 status doesn’t mean automatic eligibility for EB-1 extraordinary ability. EB-1 has a higher bar. This visa has a high bar. The foreign national must have national or international acclaim and provide evidence of awards and publicity. This visa is frequently used by top actors, musicians, and scientists.
P-1 Visa for Entertainment and Athletic Groups: P-1, P-2 and P-3
For both P-1A and P-1B, the foreign national can bring essential support personnel as well (P-1S).
The Process
Your U.S. employer must submit a Form I-129, Petition for a Non-Immigrant Worker accompanied by the appropriate fee and supporting documentation.
Supporting Documents
Form I-129 must include the following documents:
- Written consultation from an appropriate labor organization regarding the nature of the work to be done or a statement proving that the group has been established and performing regularly for a period of at least one year. (If no appropriate labor organization exists, this requirement is excused.)
- Itinerary with the dates and locations of the performances
- A copy of the contract between the petitioner and the beneficiary or summary of terms of the oral agreement under which the beneficiary will be employed
- Evidence that your group has been established and performing regularly for at least one year
- Statement from the petitioner listing each member of the group and the exact dates for which each member has been employed on a regular basis by the group
- Evidence that your group is internationally recognized as outstanding in the discipline for a sustained and substantial period of time as demonstrated by evidence of your group’s receipt of, or nomination for, significant international awards or prizes for outstanding achievement in the field, or evidence of at least three of the following:
o Your group has performed and will perform as a starring or leading entertainment group in production or events which have a distinguished reputation as evidenced by critical reviews, advertisements, publicity releases, publications, contracts, or endorsements;
o Your group has achieved international recognition and acclaim for outstanding achievement in its field as evidenced by reviews in major newspapers, trade journals, magazines or other published material;
o Your group has performed and will perform services as a leading or starring group for organizations and establishments that have a distinguished reputation as evidenced by articles in newspapers, trade journals, publications, or testimonials;
o Your group has a record of major commercial or critically acclaimed successes, as evidenced by indicators such as ratings, box office receipts, record, cassette or video sales, and other achievements as reported in trade journals, major newspapers or other publications;
o Your group has received significant recognition for achievements from critics, organizations, government agencies or other recognized experts in the field;
o Your group has commanded and will command a high salary or other substantial remuneration for services comparable to others similarly situated in the field, as evidenced by contracts or other reliable evidence.
Period of Stay/Extension of Stay
Initial Period of Stay | Extension of Stay |
Time needed to complete the event, competition or performance, not to exceed 1 year | Increments of up to 1 year in order to continue or complete the event, competition or performance. |
Temporary Nonimmigrant Religious Workers: R-1
An R-1 is a foreign national who is coming to the United States temporarily to be employed as a minister or in another religious vocation or occupation at least part time (average of at least 20 hours per week) by:
- A non-profit religious organization in the United States;
- A religious organization that is authorized by a group tax exemption holder to use its group tax exemption; or
- A non-profit religious organization which is affiliated with a religious denomination in the United States.
This visa program is intended for religious workers whose lives are dedicated to religious practices and functions, as distinguished from secular members of the religion.
To qualify, the foreign national must have been a member of a religious denomination having a bona fide non-profit religious organization in the United States for at least two years immediately before the filing of the petition.
Religious occupations are defined as occupations whose duties must:
- Primarily relate to a traditional religious function;
- Be recognized as a religious occupation within the denomination; and
- Be primarily related to, and clearly involve, inculcating or carrying out the religious creed and beliefs of the denomination.
Process:
1. A prospective or existing U.S. employer must file Form I-129, Petition for Nonimmigrant Worker, on behalf of foreign nationals seeking to enter the United States as a nonimmigrant minister, or a religious worker in a religious vocation or occupation.
An R-1 visa cannot be issued at a U.S. Embassy or Consulate abroad without prior USCIS approval of Form I-129. This process allows USCIS to review the petition to determine whether the petitioning organization and the beneficiary have met their respective eligibility requirements for this nonimmigrant classification.
2. Upon approval of the petition, the consular post then determines whether the foreign national is eligible to receive the R-1 nonimmigrant visa. As with all individuals who appear at ports of entry, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) determines whether the beneficiary may be admitted to the United States.
3. Visa exempt workers must present the original Form I-797, Notice of Action, at a port of entry as evidence of an approved Form I-129 R petition.
4. Along with Form I-129, the petitioner must include evidence of eligibility for the classification sought. Both the petitioning organization and the religious worker must satisfy certain requirements, which are discussed below.
Petitioner Requirements- these pieces of evidence that must be submitted to establish eligibility to file Form I-129 for an R-1 nonimmigrant.
- A bona fide non-profit religious organization and has its own individual Internal Revenue Service (IRS) 501(c)(3) letter
- Proof of salaried or non-salaried compensation: Religious workers generally must be compensated. Compensation may include either salaried or non-salaried compensation.
Beneficiary to be eligible as an R-1 nonimmigrant.
Proof of membership (for all cases): Provide evidence that the religious worker is a member of a religious denomination having a bona fide non-profit religious organization in the United States for at least two years immediately before the filing of Form I-129.
On-Site Visits by USCIS
Under the regulations at 8 CFR 214.2(r)(16), USCIS may conduct a pre-approval inspection in any case. If USCIS decides to conduct a pre-approval inspection, satisfactory completion of the inspection will be a condition for approval of any petition.
A physical address where constituents generally congregate to worship must be provided in order for USCIS to conduct a pre-approval site inspection, even if that address is not the same as the mailing address. During a site inspection, USCIS must verify that the place of worship/congregation actually exists.
In addition, a post-adjudication inspection may be completed on the beneficiary’s work location to verify the beneficiary’s work hours, compensation and duties.
A post-adjudication inspection may also be conducted in cases of suspected fraud or where the petitioning entity has undergone substantial changes since its last filing. USCIS closely monitors the site visit program to ensure that it does not cause substantial delays in the adjudication process.
Period of stay
USCIS may grant R-1 status for an initial period of admission for up to 30 months. Subsequent extensions may be granted for up to an additional 30 months. The religious worker’s total period of stay in the United States in R-1 classification cannot exceed five years (60 months).
Family
An R-1 religious worker’s spouse and unmarried children under the age of 21 may be eligible for R-2 classification. An R-2 dependent is not authorized to accept employment based on this visa classification.
Changes in location of employment may constitute material changes to the terms and conditions of employment as specified in the original approved R-1 petition. If there is a material change in the terms or conditions of employment (or the beneficiary’s eligibility), the petitioner may be required to file an amended petition and receive an approval prior to the beneficiary’s move to a location of employment other than that listed on the original approved R-1 petition.
Road to Green Card
R-1 visa holders who are currently working in the U.S. as ministers or in a religious vocation or occupation have a fairly simple route to obtaining a green card to become U.S. lawful permanent residents.
– We will discuss this in employment-based petitions
The H-2A program allows U.S. employers or U.S. agents who meet specific regulatory requirements to bring foreign nationals to the United States to fill temporary agricultural jobs
– Employer files I-129 form w/ USCIS
To qualify for H-2A nonimmigrant classification, the petitioner must:
- Offer a job that is of a temporary or seasonal nature.
- Demonstrate that there are not enough U.S. workers who are able, willing, qualified, and available to do the temporary work.
- Show that employing H-2A workers will not adversely affect the wages and working conditions of similarly employed U.S. workers.
- Generally, submit a single valid temporary labor certification from the U.S. Department of Labor with the H-2A petition. (A limited exception to this requirement exists in certain “emergent circumstances.” See e.g., 8 CFR 214.2(h)(5)(x) for specific details.)
Process
Step 1: Petitioner submits temporary labor certification application to the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL). Before requesting H-2A classification from USCIS, the petitioner must apply for and receive a temporary labor certification for H-2A workers from DOL
see the Foreign Labor Certification, Department of Labor Web page.
Step 2: Petitioner submits Form I-129 to USCIS. After receiving a temporary labor certification for H-2A employment from DOL, the petitioner must file Form I-129 with USCIS.
Step 3: Prospective workers outside the United States apply for visa and/or admission. After USCIS approves Form I-129, prospective H-2A workers who are outside the United States must:
- Apply for an H-2A visa with the U.S. Department of State (DOS) at a U.S. Embassy or Consulate abroad and then seek admission to the United States with U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) at a U.S. port of entry; or
- Directly seek admission to the United States in H-2A classification with CBP at a U.S. port of entry, if a worker does not require a visa in cases where an H-2A visa is not required.
Waivers
Non-Immigrant Visa Waiver
The waiver allows an NIV applicant to overcome the grounds of inadmissibility and be granted a NIV visa. It is adjudicated at the Consulate abroad. If the consular officer recommends the Waiver for approval- the case is sent to Admissibility Review Office in Washington D.C. for a final decision.
The Hranka Waiver (see also Inadmissibility, Deportation and Waivers)
The Hranka Waiver INA §212(d)(3) is an immigration court case- Matter of Hranka. It dictates the sets of 3 factors that immigration authorities must consider when deciding whether to grant the waiver:
1. the risk of harm to society if a waiver applicant is admitted to the U.S
2. the seriousness of an applicant’s prior criminal or immigration violations, if any, and
3. the nature of the applicant’s reason for wishing to enter the U.S.
Immigrant Visa
• Family-Based Immigration
• Employment-Based Immigration
Family Based Immigration
Introduction/Overview
Quotas
Each fiscal year 226,000 annual visas are available for family-based sponsorships by United States Citizens (USCs) and Lawful Permanent Residents (LPRs). Each country receives 7% of the total annual family-sponsored and employment-based immigrant visas to be allocated. This gives rise to the preference categories- see:
https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal/visa-law0/visa-bulletin.html
Chargeability and Cross-Chargeability
Country of Chargeability
For the purposes of the allocated visas, the country of chargeability is used. The country of chargeability is the country of birth, not of nationality/citizenship. For example, if you are born in the Phillipines, your country of chargeability is the Phillipines and your visa comes from those allocated to that country. Children may be charged to their parents’ country if accompanying or following to join (FTJ), INA §§203(d), 216(g), 22 CFR §42.12(b); 9 FAM 42.12 N3. The spouse may be charged to the spouse’s country, if accompanying or FTJ, INA §§203(d), 216(g), 22 CFR §42.12(c).
Cross-Chargeability
Cross-chargeability is when you use the nationality of the dependent spouse/child to get a benefit in the country quota allocation system even though the derivative may NOT be the principal beneficiary of the IV application.
Immediate Relatives (IR) – Preferential Treatment
Immediate relatives of US citizens get preferential treatment. They are not subject to INA§203 visa preference categories (such as F1, F2, etc.). Immediate relatives do not have to wait in the Visa wait line like other relatives do.
Immediate relatives are:
1- Spouses of citizens,
2- Children (under 21 years of age and unmarried) of citizens, and
3- Parents of citizens (21 years or older USC).
No visa quota numbers apply to Immediate Relatives; therefore, they can do Adjustment of Status in the country (even if out of status as long as they were admitted to the United States in lawful status).
Example: A child can age out of immediate relative status. For example, if you have a child of a USC- over 21 now- unless CSPA protected them- they will now be an F1 (visa preference category) and will not be an immediate relative. Now he/she must wait in the visa wait line and it affects whether a person qualifies at all.
• If this child was also an entry without inspection, then they are an EWI and an F1 (an INA§203 preference category) hence NOT qualified for Adjustment of Status within the country unless grandfathered in by 245 i. (At 18.5 years a child starts accruing unlawful status.)
Whom a USC and Whom an LPR Can Sponsor
United States Citizens (USCs) and Lawful Permanent Residents (LPRs) can sponsor and bring their relatives from abroad to join them in the United States by filing an I-130 (Petition for Alien Relative). This is just the first step of the sponsorship process. In this section we will educate you on the relative categories that can be sponsored and the timelines for their immigration process.
USCs can sponsor:
- Parents
- Spouses
- Fiancés
- Children (married and unmarried)
- Siblings
LPRs can sponsor:
- Spouses
- Children (under 21, but if over 21, they must be unmarried)
Children- INA §101(b)
Biological Child:
- Unmarried under 21 years of age
- The child must either be born in wedlock, or a stepchild- only where the marriage occurred before the child turned 18. If they are from an out of wedlock birth to a USC mother or father, you need to show a birth certificate to establish the biological relationship PLUS show a bona fide parent-child relationship (through financial support, school records).
Adoptive Children
The adoption must have been entered into before the child turned 16. There has to be legal custody and the child has to have resided with adoptive parents for 2 years. Exception: If the child was battered by parent or another member of the household. The adoptive child cannot ever petition for natural parents. Their siblings could be adopted for family unity.
Orphans:
In Non-Hague Convention Countries
You are a U.S. citizen.
If you are married, your spouse must also sign Form I-600, Petition to Classify Orphan as an Immediate Relative and must also adopt the child. If you are not married, you must be at least 25 years old when you file your Form I-600 petition.
You must establish that:
- You will provide proper parental care to the child.
- The child whom you have adopted or plan to adopt is an “orphan” as defined in U.S. immigration law.
- Either: (1) You (and your spouse, if married) have adopted the child abroad, and that at least 1 of you personally saw and observed the child before or during the adoption proceedings OR (2) You will adopt the child in the United States after the child arrives in the United States (you must have permission to bring the child out of his or her own country and to the United States for adoption).
Hague Convention Countries Only
This is for home study abroad. You choose a Hague Accredited Adoption Service Provider (ASP) (and perhaps also an immigration attorney). You must:
- Obtain a home study from someone authorized to complete a Hague adoption home study.
- Apply to USCIS before adopting a child or accepting a placement for a determination that one is suitable for intercountry adoption.
- Once USCIS approves the application, work with the adoption service provider to obtain a proposed adoption placement.
- File a “petition” with USCIS, before adopting the child, to have the child to be found eligible to immigrate to the United States based on the proposed adoption.
- Adopt the child, or obtain custody of the child in order to adopt the child in the United States.
- Obtain an immigrant visa for the child.
- Bring the child to the United States for admission with the visa.
Child of an LPR
If the child of an LPR is over 21, they are F2b; However, if they get married, then there is no more IV for them, no category at all. You can’t recapture the time they were waiting- must be qualified at the time of receiving their green card.
If a child of a USC- who is in category F1 – then they get married, now they are F3 (with Adjustment of Status or 245i).
Children of those under INA § 203 category (preference categories) have derivative relatives.
Immediate relatives have NO derivatives so an individual petition is needed for each person, e.g. LPR naturalizes- their child upgrade category- can OPT out of automatic upgrade.
Letter to resist moving from F2B to F1 (204K) and if they want to switch the category back they need to write another letter.
Child Status Protection Act (CSPA), PL 107-208, 116 Stat. 927 (Aug. 6, 2002): INA§§ 201(t) and 203(h)
This act applies to children who turned 21 after August 6, 2002. It only applies to these children and is NOT retroactive! It also only applies to IV petitions, petitions filed or approved on or after August 6, 2002.
ADJUSTMENT OF STATUS/visa application pending on or after August 6, 2002
For a visa petition approved before August 6, 2002 but no final decision on ADJUSTMENT OF STATUS/visa application before then- “final decision” includes court litigation/appeals, Memo, Williams, Ex. Assoc. Comm. Office of Field Operations, INS, HQADN 70/6.1.1 (Feb. 14, 2003).
Aged-out children will have petitions automatically converted to another preference category, and retain the priority date, INA§203(h)(3); this applies to derivative beneficiaries in the F2 category.
Must Do Adjustment of Status or Consular Processing Within ONE Year of Visa Availability
“Available” means the first day of the applicable visa bulletin month- per United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) and Department of State (DOS).
There is an opt-out provision for conversion upon naturalization of a petitioning parent, §204(k)(2);
The conversion from F2b toF1 is problem for some countries because of the backlog.
CSPA Formula
To apply the statute INA §203 (h), subtract the current age at the time the visa is current – minus the number of days that visa is pending -age at the time of I-130 approval, then that age is protected (MUST have sought to acquire the visa within ONE year of the visa becoming current). If after formula the child is still over 21 then INA§203 h3 applies.
Statute INA §203 h (3) only applies to F2As that go to F2Bs!narrowly applied e.g. child of LPR- 21 retains priority date as long as he or she does not get married.
Form I-130, Petition for Alien Relative
This form is used to petition for a relative who is either an immediate relative (child, spouse, parent), or has a certain preference category (brother or sister, for example). While US citizens can petition for siblings as well as children over 21, married or single, an LPR can only petition for a spouse and unmarried children of any age. While blood relatives need only provide birth certificates to prove relationship, spouses must provide evidence of the bona fides of the relationship, so as to combat marriage fraud (marriage for the purpose of citizenship).
If the petition (Form I-130, Petition for Alien Relative) was filed by a U.S. citizen parent for his or her child, the beneficiary’s age “freezes” on the date of filing.
If the petition (Form I-130) was filed by a permanent resident parent and the parent naturalizes before the beneficiary turns 21, the beneficiary’s age “freezes” on the date the petitioner naturalized.
CSPA allows the time a visa petition was pending to be subtracted from the beneficiary’s biological age at the time of visa availability, so that the applicant is not penalized for the time in which USCIS did not adjudicate the petition.
Marriage Cases
Both USCs and LPRs can petition for their spouses abroad- the following complications may arise before they live happily ever after in the United States.
Good Faith Marriage (GFM)
This is hard to prove. The process is designed to prevent marriage fraud. This is a big issue. One case in which GFM would need to be proved would be that of an LPR petitioner who obtained LPR status through a prior marriage petition INA§204(a)(2)(A). Also, if you got a green card and then got married to someone else from home country within the past 5 years of dissolution, there is a very high burden of proof on you to prove that this is a GFM.
INA§ 204(c) Prohibition for prior marriage fraud committed by beneficiary: INA§ 204(c)
Polygamous marriages are NOT recognizable in the USA. If a polygamous marriage exists the Petitioner can only bring the first wife to the USA, since this is the only marriage considered legal in the U.S.
Proxy Marriages
This is when one of the contracting parties is not present for the marriage ceremony. A proxy marriage is only recognized for the US Immigration when consummated.
Marriage During Removal Proceedings: Must Demonstrate Bona fide per INA§204(g) and245(e)
While getting married to a USC while in deportation-seeking Adjustment of Status in front of EOIR judge, the Burden of Proof is the clear and convincing standard. That is, the Burden of Proof is clear and convincing evidence that this is a Good Faith Marriage. There is a higher burden of proof to overcome the presumption that this marriage was entered into to avoid/get relief form removal. INA§24(e)- a waiver that requires a person in removal to leave the US for 2 years must be referenced at the time if filing the family-based petition in removal.
Widows/Widowers: INA§ 20 l(b)(2)(A)(I)- Must file within 2 years of death of the USC/LPR sponsoring spouse.
Immigration and Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA)/Same-Sex Marriages:
USCIS and the Department of State have indicated these marriages will be treated the same as a heterosexual marriage, citing SCOTUS U.S. v.Windsor.
Determining Whether Preference Petition Is Current
Country of Chargeability
This is the country of birth, not nationality/citizenship.
Children may be charged to the parents’ country, if accompanying, or following to join – INA §§203(d), 216(g), 22 CFR §42.12(b); 9 FAM 42.12 N3
Spouse may be charged to spouse’s country, if accompanying, or FTJ – INA §§203(d), 216(g), 22 CFR §42.12(c)
Procedures: Obtaining the Green Card
(Adjustment of Status Under §245 a, c, k, i)
To be able to do ADJUSTMENT OF STATUS a person must have been “Inspected and admitted or paroled,” which includes:
- Waved through at the border
- If fraudulent documents are used at entry, you need a 212i to waive misrepresentation at the border crossing- there has to be affirmative misrepresentation waiver to waive the fraud.
The Adjustment of Status Application
The following forms and exhibits are required:
• Form G-28, Notice of Entry of Appearance of Attorney or Accredited Representative
• Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status
- Form G-325, Biographic Information, which gathers biographical information about the applicant only
- Evidence of lawful entry into the US, either through a Form I-94 Arrival/Departure Record or passport stamp
- Birth Certificate of applicant, with notarized translation, if applicable
- Results of medical examination, on I-693, which is prepared by the civil surgeon and place into a sealed envelope that must remain unopened
- Form I-864, Affidavit of Support, with supporting documents
- If applicable, certified dispositions of any arrests
- Form I-765, Application for Employment Authorization Document, if desired
- Form I-131, Application for Travel Document, if needed
- Form I-797, Approval Notice for previously approved Form I-130 petition or, if the beneficiary is an immediate relative filing concurrently, the petitioner’s Form I-130 application with all supporting documentation
- Immigration Filing Fees (Checks or money order made out to DHS)
- Two passport photos
Adjustment of Status Plus I-131
The Adjustment of Status applicant must remain in the US until green card (I-485 Adjustment of Status application) is adjudicated/granted otherwise the Adjustment of Status application is considered abandoned if they leave while it’s pending.
But if they have an urgent need to travel, they must obtain an Application to Travel Document permit (via I-131) so that they can leave temporarily and come back to resume the processing of their Adjustment of Status.
Consular Processing – Through NVC
File Form I-824: Request for Action File this form to start your case with NVC if the priority date is current. Beneficiary can abandon/lose this Visa available if:
- No action taken within 1 year of Visa becoming available
- Fees aren’t paid in a timely manner
- Petitioner withdraws the visa applications
- Beneficiary dies – terminates the benefits for the derivative
File form DS 260 and fee
Waiver:
If beneficiary is present in the US unlawfully- 601= waived fraud waiver based on hardship to parent/spouse who is LPR or USC- people who would trigger the 3 or 10- year bar if they leave the US before leaving the US. You must notify NVC about any 601 Waiver. (See Inadmissibility, Deportation and Waivers.)
Adjustment of Status and Consular Processing- Immigrant Visa Beneficiaries NEED I-864
The “Affidavit of Support” (I-864) is a signed form by a USC that tells USCIS that a USC would take financial responsibility for sponsored beneficiary of an IV who is seeking a green card. The person signing this Affidavit of Support becomes the “financial sponsor.” Therefore, in the future, after getting a green card, if the sponsored alien goes on to receive means-tested befits- the US government reserves the right to sue the financial sponsor to reimburse the government for the benefits that the sponsored alien took from the means tested benefits. The financial sponsor does NOT have to be the same person that sponsored the foreign national. If sponsoring spouse does not have adequate income- then they will need a co-sponsor for I-864 – can be ANYONE age 18 and a USC with sufficient income- see https://www.uscis.gov/i-864p. This obligation does not end until: • The sponsored alien becomes a United States Citizen. • Financial sponsor dies • The sponsored beneficiary dies • The sponsored beneficiary completes 40 qualifying quarters of Social Security benefits in the US (i.e. has worked in the US for 10 years and basis federal taxes)
K-Visa
A K-Visa is for a foreign national who is not yet married but who is engaged, who may not know where they will live after marriage or who may want to marry in the United States. You cannot be sponsored by an I-130 since you are not married. But you can enter the USA on a K-1 visa, along with any unmarried children under 21 (on K-2 visas), as long as sponsored by a USC (not an LPR). The desired form is the Form I-129f, Petition for Alien Fiancée. For the couple to be eligible for this kind of sponsorship they must be able to show that they met within 2 years of filing the form, unless they can show cultural exceptions. They also must also marry within 90 days of entry on the K-Visa.
Conditional Lawful Permanent Resident Status
The Conditional Lawful Permanent Resident (LPR) statute applies to those cases in which the marriage is less than 2 years old at time of adjudication of application or entry into US. An applicant can file removal of conditions (Form I-751) up to 90 days prior to termination of 2-year conditional period. I-751 must be filed jointly by spouses.
Exceptions to Joint Filing for Conditional LPRs
Exception: INA §216(c)(4) – allows applicant to apply for waiver:
• A good faith marriage ended through divorce or annulment,
• Foreign national will experience extreme hardship if not allowed to remain in US, or
• Foreign national was battered/extreme cruelty by USC or LPR spouse
Abandonment of LPR Status
Suppose the LPR left the U.S. for 1 year, did he abandon his LPR? If there is an absence of more than 1 year, the LPR is deemed abandoned. If gone less than one year, she or he still needs to show intent not to abandon. If they leave for more than 6 months, the presumption is that they abandoned status of LPR. The burden of proof is on the LPR to show they did not mean to abandon their status – e.g. maybe they could show dying parents outside the US etc. but show ties to country (continuous intent to not abandon their green card).
Our experienced immigration attorneys are here to assist you in your family-based application.
Employment-Based Immigration
Employment-Based Immigrant Visas
Employment-based visas are based on employment rather than on family relations.
First Preference EB-1- [INA §203(b), 8 CFR § 204.5]
• PRIORITY WORKERS / NO LABOR CERTIFICATION REQUIRED
1. EXTRAORDINARY ABILITY (8 CFR § 204.5(h))
2. Outstanding professors and researchers
3. Certain Multinational Managers or Executives
First Preference EB-1-A
The EB-1(A) category applies to persons of extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics through sustained national or international acclaim.
Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th. Cir. Mar. 4, 2010) increased the level of scrutiny by adding a second prong review. Three out of 10 criteria must be met. An overarching standard applies.
No labor certification or job offer required.
Federal Court decision in Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9 Cir. 2010).
USCIS now follows Kazarian’s two-step test:
(1) Determine whether the petitioner has submitted evidence that meets the standards
stated above; and
(2) Determine whether the evidence submitted is sufficient to demonstrate that the beneficiary or self-petitioner meets the required high level of expertise for the extraordinary ability preference category during a final merits determination.
Extraordinary Ability (EOA): meet 3 of the 10 criteria* below, or provide evidence of a one-time achievement (i.e., Pulitzer, Oscar, Olympic Medal)
1. Evidence of receipt of lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence
2. Evidence of your membership in associations in the field which demand outstanding achievement of their members
3. Evidence of published material about you in professional or major trade publications or other major media
4. Evidence that you have been asked to judge the work of others, either individually or on a panel
5. Evidence of your original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance to the field
6. Evidence of your authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media
7. Evidence that your work has been displayed at artistic exhibitions or showcases
8. Evidence of your performance of a leading or critical role in distinguished organizations
9. Evidence that you command a high salary or other significantly high remuneration in relation to others in the field
10. Evidence of your commercial successes in the performing arts
First Preference EB-1 Examples
• Example 1: Highly cited Scientist discovers a natural cure for acne, has results published in prominent journals, wins highest awards in the field and is asked to speak at international conferences.
• Example 2: Recognizable voice actor whose work in TV and film has gained widespread commercial success.
• Example 3: Geology student develops iPhone app that can predict earthquakes within one hour of occurrence and wins Nobel Prize.
EB-1(B): Outstanding Researcher/ Professor (8 CFR § 204.5(i))
• The EB-1(B) category covers researchers and professors with international recognition for their outstanding achievements.
• Requires full-time job offer from U.S. petitioner.
• Candidates must have at least 3 years of research or teaching experience in the field.
• Must be offered tenure track or permanent position. Private companies require division or group with at least 3 full-time researchers and documented
accomplishments in the field to be eligible to sponsor. Must meet 2 out of 6 criteria. Overarching standard.
• No labor certification BUT job offer required.
• 2 out of 6 criteria. Overarching standard.
• Evidence of receipt of major prizes or awards for outstanding achievement
• Evidence of membership in associations that require their members to demonstrate outstanding achievement
• Evidence of published material in professional publications written by others about the alien’s work in the academic field
• Evidence of participation, either on a panel or individually, as a judge of the work of others in the same or allied academic field
• Evidence of original scientific or scholarly research contributions in the field
• Evidence of authorship of scholarly books or articles (in scholarly journals with international circulation) in the field
Example: While working towards PhD, researcher discovers a faster way for databases to communicate with each other. After graduation and published results in prominent journals, is offered a job with an IT company. Also asked to be on peer-review panel for a prestigious conference, and invited to join a prestigious organization that requires outstanding achievements by its members.
EB-1(3): Multinational Executive and Managers (8 CFR § 204.5 (j))
The EB-1(3) category applies to persons who have been employed abroad for at least 1 year in the preceding 3 years in a managerial or executive capacity and are entering the U.S. to perform managerial or executive duties for the same company, affiliate, branch parent or subsidiary. Note the functional manager who may oversee an essential function of a company but not have any direct subordinate reports. Requires full-time job offer by U.S. petitioner.
• No labor certification BUT job offer required.
Example 1: Automobile manufacturer needs to transfer a Senior Engineer in charge of their German-based Anti-Crash Safety Division to their new U.S. based Hybrid Facility in Mojave, California on a full-time and permanent basis.
Example 2: Small Italian Company that develops niche motorcycle accessories wants to send their VP to the U.S. to lead U.S. based sales and marketing operations.
Second Preference EB-2
[INA §203(b), 8 CFR § 204.5 (k) Advanced Degree]
1. Advanced Degree
2. Exceptional Ability
3. National Interest Waiver
This situation requires labor certification and a full-time job offer. (See National Interest Waiver (NIW) exception to labor certification below.) This requires the U.S. employer to offer a permanent full-time position that requires at least a U.S. Master’s degree or foreign equivalent degree and the foreign national (FN) possesses the degree. A Bachelor’s degree followed by 5 years of progressive experience in the field is also considered an advanced degree.
• The job you apply for must require an advanced degree and you must possess such a degree or its foreign equivalent (a baccalaureate or foreign equivalent degree plus 5 years of post- baccalaureate, progressive work experience in the field). You must meet any other requirements specified on the labor certification as applicable.
• Documentation, such as an official academic record showing that you have a U.S. advanced degree or a foreign equivalent degree, or an official academic record showing that you have a U.S. baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree and letters from current or former employers showing that you have at least 5 years of progressive post-baccalaureate work experience in the specialty.
https://www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/permanent-workers/employment-based-immigration-second-preference-eb-2
• Requires labor certification and full-time job offer. (See NIW exception to labor certification below.)
• Requires the U.S. employer to offer a permanent full-time position that requires at least a:
o U.S. Master’s degree or foreign equivalent degree and the FN possesses the degree. OR a
o A Bachelor’s degree followed by 5 years of progressive experience in the field is also considered an advanced degree.
Example 1: Software Company seeks a computer programmer with a Master’s degree who is capable of developing mobile applications on android and iOS platforms.
Example 2: Investment Bank seeks Economist with a Master’s degree in Finance or Economics and two years in debt restructuring.
Exceptional ability – EB-2
Defined as a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily. Encountered in the sciences, arts, or business. Standard not as high as EB-1(1) and EB-1(2).
Petitioner must be able to show exceptional ability in the sciences, arts, or business. Exceptional ability “means a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the sciences, arts, or business.” You must meet any requirements specified on the labor certification as applicable.
Must meet 3 of the below criteria:
1. Official academic record showing that you have a degree, diploma, certificate, or similar award from a college, university, school, or other institution of learning relating to your area of exceptional ability
2. Letters documenting at least 10 years of full-time experience in your occupation
3. A license to practice your profession or certification for your profession or occupation
4. Evidence that you have commanded a salary or other remuneration for services that demonstrates your exceptional ability
5. Membership in a professional association(s)
6. Recognition for your achievements and significant contributions to your industry or field by your peers, government entities, professional or business organizations
7. Other comparable evidence of eligibility is also acceptable.
Second Preference EB-2- Exceptional Ability (Paired with NIW)
Aliens seeking a national interest waiver are requesting that the Labor Certification be waived because it is in the interest of the United States.
Those seeking a national interest waiver may self-petition (they do not need an employer to sponsor them) and may file their labor certification directly with USCIS along with their Form I-140, Immigration Petition for Alien Worker.
In addition to providing evidence of an advanced degree or exceptional ability (described in the slides under Exceptional Ability EB-2) Petitioner must also meet the 3 National Interest Waiver criteria below** in order to demonstrate that it is in the national interest that USCIS waive the requirement of a job offer, and thus the labor certification.
NIW – Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884. (AAO 2016)
Under Dhanasar, the new test is as follows:
1. The proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance;
2. The foreign national is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor; and
3. On balance, it would be beneficial to the U.S. to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification.
The term “national interest” can include a number of factors:
1. Improving the U.S. economy.
2. Improving the wages and working conditions of U.S. workers.
3. Improving education and training programs for American children and under-qualified workers.
4. Improving health care.
5. Providing affordable housing.
6. Improving the environment.
7. The request of an interested agency within the U.S. government.
The petition must provide persuasive evidence that the individual’s contribution would be significant enough that the national interest would be harmed if the petitioner were forced to undergo through the usual requirement of a labor certification.
Third Preference EB-3 INA §203(b), 8 CFR § 204.5 (l)
For this category, a permanent job certification by the Department of Labor is required, along with a job offer, and a 4-year degree.
1. Skilled Workers
Labor certification and a permanent, full-time job offer required.
2. Professionals
Labor certification and a permanent, full-time job offer required
3. Unskilled Workers (Other Workers)
Labor certification and a permanent, full-time job offer required
EB-3 Professional
The US Employer must offer a full-time job that requires at least a U.S. Bachelor’s degree or foreign equivalent degree. It also requires labor certification.
Example: U.S. Software Company seeks a Software Engineer with a degree in Computer Science or Engineering to develop mobile applications for the latest smartphones.
The employee (foreign national) must:
- be able to demonstrate that she or he possesses a U.S. baccalaureate degree or foreign degree equivalent, and that a baccalaureate degree is the normal requirement for entry into the occupation. (Education and experience may not be substituted for a baccalaureate degree.)
- be performing work for which qualified workers are not available in the United States.
EB-3 Skilled Labor
Requires labor certification. The employer must offer a full-time job that requires at least 2 years of experience or training. Example: Oil and Gas Service Engineering Company seeks welder with at least 5 years of experience in the field.
EB-3 Unskilled Labor
Requires labor certification. The employer must offer full-time job that can require less than 2 years of experience. Example: Restaurant seeks a cook with at least one year of experience cooking traditional Caribbean and Central American dishes. Suppose that they can’t find a minimally qualified USC/LPR Asylee or refugee for this job.
• The employer must prove that they cannot find a minimally qualified USC/LPR Asylee or refugee for this job
Schedule A, Group I/II
• Schedule A occupations are pre-certified occupations such that the Department of Labor (DOL) has already determined that there are not sufficient U.S. workers who are able, willing or qualified and wages and working conditions of U.S. workers will not be adversely affected.
• Group I covers physical therapists and registered nurses.
• Group II covers aliens of exceptional ability (as defined by DOL not to be confused with EB-2 exceptional ability). DOL Exceptional Ability.
Schedule A, Skip the PERM Requirements
For a few occupations, however, the Department of Labor (DOL) has made a blanket determination that sufficient numbers of U.S. workers are unavailable, and that the hiring of non-U.S. workers will not negatively affect U.S. wages.
These occupations are listed on DOL’s “Schedule A”, and employers hiring non-U.S.
workers for these occupations can skip the PERM process (save up to 6 months- a year of process before filing of I-140, Immigration Petition for Alien Worker)
Schedule A, Group I Occupations and Processes
This applies to:
- Physical therapists who possess all the qualifications necessary to take the physical therapist licensing examination in the state in which they propose to practice physical therapy; and
- Professional nurses who are licensed and meet certain educational qualifications.
A US employer only performs 3 steps in connection with seeking approval to hire a non- U.S. worker under Schedule A
1. Applying for a Prevailing Wage Determination from the Labor Department;
2. Providing notice to employees of that the employer intends to file a petition seeking to hire a non-U.S. worker into a Schedule A qualifying position; and
3. Filing the I-140 petition with USCIS.
Schedule A, Group II
(Group II) standard is high – close to EB1(1) standard. Must meet 2 out of 7 requirements. Must have widespread acclaim and international recognition. See 20 CFR § 656.15.
- Documentary evidence showing the widespread acclaim and international recognition accorded the individual by recognized experts in the beneficiary’s field; and
- Documentation showing the individual’s work in that field during the past year did, and the individual’s intended work in the United States will, require exceptional ability; and
- Documentation about the individual from at least two of the following seven groups:
1. Receipt of internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence in their field;
2. Evidence of membership in associations in the individual’s field which require outstanding achievements of their members;
3. Copies of publications from professional publications relating to the individual and their work;
4. Evidence of the individual’s participation as a judge of the work of others in the same field;
5. Evidence of the individual’s original contributions of major significance to their field;
6. Evidence or authorship of published scientific or scholarly articles in international professional journals or professional journals with an international circulation; and
7. Evidence of display of the individual’s work in artistic exhibitions and showcases in more than one country.
Exceptional Ability Comparison between EB-1, EB-2 and Schedule
A Group II
Schedule A, Group II | EB-2 | EB-1 |
---|---|---|
exceptional ability in the sciences or arts |
exceptional ability | extraordinary ability |
“wide-spread acclaim and international recognition accorded the alien by recognized experts in the alien’s field” |
“a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the sciences, arts, or business” |
“one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor” |
Fourth Preference EB-4
[INA §203(b), 8 CFR § 204.5]You may be eligible for an employment-based, fourth preference visa if you are a special
immigrant. The following special immigrants are eligible for the fourth preference visa:
• Religious Workers
• Special Immigrant Juveniles
• Broadcasters
• G-4 International Organization or NATO-6 Employees and Their Family Members
• International Employees of the U.S. Government Abroad
• Armed Forces Members
• Panama Canal Zone Employees
• Certain Physicians
• Afghan and Iraqi Translators
• Afghan and Iraqi Nationals Who Have Provided Faith Service in Support of U.S. Operations
• Source:
• https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/permanent-workers/employment-based-immigration-fourth-preference-eb-4
Special Immigrants (SIV)
Examples of this include: Special Immigrant Juveniles (SIJ); Certain Panamanians; Armed Forces Members; Religious Workers; Afghan/Iraq translators who supported U.S. troops. Applications are filed on Form I-360.
Special Immigrant Juvenile (SIJ)
If a minor is in the United States and needs the protection of a juvenile court because they were abused, abandoned, or neglected by a parent, they may be eligible for Special Immigrant Juvenile (SIJ) classification. The SIJ category helps non-US citizen children in the US who have been harmed physically or mentally by one or both parents. If SIJ classification is granted, then the minor may qualify for lawful permanent residency.
The child first needs a guardianship order and then an approved I-360 form. Once these two are obtained, these children can then live and work permanently in the US. This classification allows the child to remain in the country under the care and custody of the court while applying for a green card.
In order to apply for Special Immigrant Juvenile status, a child must be under the age of 21 when they file a Form I-360 Petition. The child must also be unmarried and currently inside the US at the time the petition is submitted.
Applying for a Green Card
Once a child has met all eligibility requirements for SIJ status, it is necessary to establish eligibility for a green card. There are various reasons that cause an applicant to be ineligible for a green card but some of these do not apply to SIJ applicants including:
- The child cannot financially support himself or herself.
- The child is unlawfully present in the US.
- The child entered the US by hiding on a boat, airplane, or through other transportation.
- The child does not have a proper visa or passport.
Fifth Preference EB-5 [INA §203(b), 8 CFR § 204.6]
Direct Investment EB-5
Requires capital investment in new commercial enterprise (created after 11/29/1990) that creates/saves 10-full time jobs for U.S. workers. Capital can mean cash, equipment, and inventory and must be from a demonstrably lawful source.
One million dollars is the required amount unless the new commercial enterprise is located in a targeted employment area, where it is reduced to $500,000. In practice, tracing and documenting the funds is key to showing lawful source regardless if it was earned via employment, lent, or gifted.
If invested in a business created before 11/29/1990, the infusion of capital must restructure or reorganize into a new commercial enterprise or expand investment so that 40% increase in net-worth or employees occurs.
The foreign national must manage operations either day-to-day or through policy formulation. At least 10 full-time jobs must be created for U.S. workers. Full-time is defined at 35 hours per week.
A troubled business which is at least 2 years old and incurred a loss of 20% of net worth in 12-24 months before filing, can qualify if the investment saves existing jobs.
EB-5 Regional Center – Now Expired
Regional Center (pilot program) allows job creation to be based on reasonable methodologies (econometric report). This usually requires a $500,000 investment + subscription fee to a regional center. Direct and indirect jobs can be included in the job count. Investments are usually pooled into a pre-designated project – e.g., new hotel, shopping mall, etc.
EB-5 Immigrant Investor Regional Center Program expired at midnight on June 30, 2021.
https://www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/permanent-workers/eb-5-immigrant-investor-program
EB-5 Removal of Conditions- 8 CFR § 216.6
The removal of conditions within 90-days of grant of conditional residence is required. It cannot materially change the investment. The key is to substantially achieve everything stated in the initial I-526 petition, Immigrant Petition by Alien Entrepreneur. This application is filed on Form I-829, Petition by Investor to Remove Conditions on Permanent Resident Status.
Perm Labor Certifications (EB-2 and EB-3)- 20 CFR § 656
Program Electronic Review Management (PERM) requires a full-time job offer. It is a test of the local labor market for qualified, willing and able U.S. workers. For this the employer must conduct recruitment including prevailing wage determination.
The PERM Process: Step I:
To obtain a Prevailing Wage Determination (PWD) from the Department of Labor (DOL) in order to determine the approximate proffered wage level, use the hyperlink: http://www.flcdatacenter.com/OesWizardStart.aspx . File the PWD online.
Recruitment Process: Step II:
Mandatory: Notice of Filing posting (internal job posting): Department of Labor (DOL) regulations require an employer to post a notice of the job opportunity (“Job Posting Notice”) as part of the Permanent Employment Certification recruitment process. The job must be posted in a conspicuous location at the place the employee will work for a minimum of 10 consecutive business days. AND There must be a State Workforce Authority (SWA) posting (job order) and 2 Sunday advertisements in a newspaper of general circulation in the area of intended employment. Professional positions also require 3 out of 10 additional recruitment steps: The following ten options are available to the employer (must choose 3): 1. Place an advertisement on the company’s website: fairly easy and inexpensive to carry out. 2. Job search website other than the employers. This must be documented by providing dated print outs of the first and last day. 3. Recruit applicants at a job fair: For example, if the employer is seeking to fill a doctor’s position, it should not recruit at a computer tech job fair. 4. Engage in an employee referral program that provides incentives to current employees for recruiting new hires for the company. Typically, this consists of a company-wide email or notice explaining the job opportunity and the benefits that a current employee will receive for referring a candidate. 5. On-campus recruiting at a local college: if the job requires several years of experience, this option will not be appropriate. 6. Place an advertisement with a job-search website other than the employer’s website: free and easy. 7. Place a radio/television advertisement: expensive. 8. Place an advertisement with the campus placement office of a local college. This option is a more passive form of recruitment. 9. Place an ad with a trade/professional organization: only available to employers of industries have a professional organization. For example, the American Medical Association places an advertisement with a local or ethnic newspaper, a method that is typically less costly. 10. Place an advertisement with a private employment firm. Notably, there is no time requirement for the three additional recruitment steps. For example, an employer could place an ad on its website for just one day, or for fifteen days. Or, an employer could place an ad to run in the local newspaper for just one day, or for a full week.
The PERM Process: Step III:
At the close of the recruitment period, the employer completes (PERM) ETA Form 9089 and submits it electronically to the DOL. The ETA Form 9089 requires information about the employer’s recruitment procedure, information about the foreign worker’s education and work experience, and information about the job opportunity such as requirements, duties, position title, and so forth.
The PERM Timeline:
The job order must run for 30 consecutive calendar days (and weekends are included in the 30-day count). Because of the importance of this time frame, it is highly recommended that employers let their job orders run for longer than 30 days, such as for 35 or 36 days, to make absolutely sure to comply with the 30-day rule.
The Recruitment RULE: 30 days for State Workforce Authority and 30 days cool-off time period While the advertisements are running, the employer must review all of the resumes received for the job opportunity. If the employer cannot disqualify a candidate based upon the candidate’s resume alone, the employer must contact the person for an interview. The employer must keep detailed records of all resumes received, interviews conducted, and reasons for rejecting all applicants. Once PERM is approved…The employer files the I-140 Petition to sponsor the foreign national for the position that the DOL has approved the PERM for! Once the I-140 is approved the FN (sponsored employee) can apply for his/her green card along with family (children under 21 only and unmarried can be added as beneficiaries).
Employment Based Adjustment of Status and Consular Processing-
INA § 245 / 8 CFR § 245 / 9 FAM § 42
Adjustment of Status usually requires legal admission and maintenance of status.
1. Employment-based cases are usually handled at Service Centers unless assigned to the District Office for interview, or
2. Consular Processing (CP) requires application to be filed with National Visa Center who acts as the middleman and compiles the required documentation before sending the case to a Consulate abroad where FN will attend IV interview.
You can switch (port) employers to the same or a similar job if Adjustment of Status has been pending more than 180-days and the I-140 was approved. AC21/INA 204(j). Watch for the FN who ports before 180-days and or before the I-140 is approved. The I-140 must have been approvable when filed or the port may fail.
Consular Processing (CP) requires application to be filed with National Visa Center, which acts as the middleman and compiles the required documentation before sending the case to a Consulate abroad where the FN will attend an Immigration Visa interview.
The selection to file for adjustment or to employ consular processing is made on the Form I-140, Immigration Petition for Alien Worker.
Visa Bulletin and Priority Dates
Published monthly by the State Department, the Visa Bulletin summarizes the availability of immigrant visa numbers subject to the quota system. The INA sets an annual quota on certain preference categories.
If oversubscribed (e.g., EB-2/3 for FN born in India or China PRC), a waiting line ensues. Visa numbers are only available to applicants whose priority dates are earlier than the cut-off date. The priority date is acquired when the labor certification or immigrant preference petition is filed. Once an immigrant petition is approved, the FN can generally retain the priority date for subsequent immigrant petition filings. See 8 CFR
§ 204.5 (e).
The Diversity Immigrant Visa Program
The Diversity Immigrant Visa Program (DV Program) makes up to 50,000 immigrant visas available annually, drawn from random selection among all entries to individuals who are from countries with low rates of immigration to the United States. The DV Program is administered by the U.S. Department of State (DOS).
Most lottery winners reside outside the United States and immigrate through consular processing and issuance of an immigrant visa. To learn more, visit the U.S. Department of State’s website.
Eligibility Criteria
For an applicant to adjust status under the DV Program, you must establish that you:
- Have been selected for a diversity visa by DOS’s lottery;
- Have an immigrant visa immediately available at the time of filing an adjustment application (Form I-485, Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status); and
- Are admissible to the United States.
Diversity Visa- Ineligible Countries
Those born in any territory that has sent more than 50,000 immigrants to the United States in the previous five years are not eligible to receive a diversity visa. For DV-2020 (the most recent lottery, with entry period in 2018), natives of the following nations are ineligible:
1. Bangladesh,
2. Brazil,
3. Canada,
4. China (mainland-born),
5. Colombia,
6. Dominican Republic,
7. El Salvador,
8. Haiti,
9. India,
10. Jamaica,
11. Mexico,
12. Nigeria,
13. Pakistan,
14. Peru, Philippines,
15. South Korea, United Kingdom and its dependent territories (except Northern Ireland), and
16. Vietnam
Asylum and Removal Defense
• Asylum
• Immigration Court and Relief from Removal
Refugees v. Asylum Status
A Refugee is a foreign national fleeing persecution from their home country. They receive their refugee status outside the US and fly to the US and enter with a refugee status. They apply for a green card within one year of their entry in the US.
Asylees are individuals present in the US applying for protection- asylum seekers.
Asylum Law
An application for asylum is based on §208 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), or alternatively, withholding of removal under INA §241(b)(3), or relief under the Convention Against Torture. INA §208.17; 8 C.F.R. 08.16(c)(3).
To be granted asylum, the Applicant must demonstrate that she or he falls within the definition of a refugee under §101(a)(42)(A) of the Immigration and Naturalization Act; which defines a refugee as:
“Any person who is outside any country of such person’s nationality or in the case of a person having non-nationality, is outside any country in which such person last habitually resided, and who is unable or unwilling to return to, and is unable or unwilling to avail himself or herself of the protection of that country because of persecution or a well-founded fear of persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion.”
The Code Federal Regulations (CFR) state that in order to be granted Asylum, the Applicant has the burden of proof to establish:
(1) past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution, and
(2) persecution on account of one of the five numerated grounds: race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. 8 C.F.R. §208.13.
Persecution- Asylum
There is no statutory definition of persecution. However, the Ninth Circuit defines persecution as the infliction of suffering or harm upon those who differ …in a way regarded as offensive.” Sangha v. INS, 103 F.3d 1482, 1487 (9th Cir. 1997). This definition of persecution is objective in that it turns not on the subjective intent of the persecutor but rather on what a reasonable person would deem “offensive.” Pitcherskaia v. INS, 118 F.3d 641, 647 (9th Cir. 1997). Persecution covers a range of acts and harms and “the determination that actions rise to the level of persecution is very fact-dependent.” Cordon-Garcia v. INS, 204 F.3d 985, 991 (9th Cir. 2000).
Forms of Persecution
Various forms of physical violence, including rape, torture, assault and beatings amount to persecution. See Chand v. INS, 222 F.3d 1066 (9th Cir. 2000) (Physical harm has consistently been treated as persecution.); Bondarenko v. Holder, 733 F.3d 899 (9th Cir. 2013) (Detained three times, severely beaten, hit in the head with such force that he was hospitalized for three days); Vitug v. Holder, 723 F.3d 1056 (9th Cir. 2013) (Beaten multiple times over a period of years, and personally experiences being threatened and harassed by police in the Philippines); Guo 361 F.3d at 1203(two arrests and repeated beating constituted persecution).
Based on past persecution, Respondent has a presumption of future persecution.
One of the elements for asylum is a well-founded fear of persecution. INA §101(a)(42)(A). Past persecution establishes a statutory presumption that, if returned to the country of origin, the applicant will suffer future persecution on the same grounds as past persecution. 8 C.F.R. §1208.13(b)(1). This presumption is only rebuttable by evidence of changed circumstances in the country from which the applicant fled or the reasonable possibility of safe internal relocation. Id.
Rebutting the Presumption of a Well-Founded Fear: Government’s Burden
In order to meet its burden under 8 C.F.R. §208.13(b)(1), the government is “obligated to introduce evidence that, on an individualized basis, rebuts a particular applicant’s specific grounds for his well-founded fear of future persecution.” Popova v. INS, 273 F.3d 1251, 1259 (9th Cir. 2001). The Courts precedent established that in such cases, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) must provide an individualized analysis of how changed conditions will affect the specific petitioner’s situation. Lopez v. Ashcroft, 366 F.3d 799, 805 (9th Cir. 2004). Information about general changes in the country is not sufficient. Garrovillas v. INS, 156 F.3d 1010, 1017 (9th Cir. 1998).
Even independently of this presumption (of past persecution), Respondent can satisfy both the subjective and objective components necessary to establish well-founded fear of future persecution if:
Even in the absence of past persecution, an applicant may be eligible for asylum based on a well-founded fear of future persecution. 8 C.F.R. §1208.13(b). In order to determine what constitutes a “well-founded fear,” the courts have stated that the standard contains two components: an objective one and a subjective one. Rodriguez-Rivera v. INS, 848 F.2d 998 at 1001 (9th Cir. 1988). The court explained that:
“The well-founded fear standard requires an examination of the asylum applicant’s subjective feelings that he or she will be persecuted, along with an examination of the objective nature of the articulated reasons for the alien’s fear of persecution. The subjective component requires that the fear be genuine, while the objective component requires a showing by credible, direct, and specific evidence in the record, of facts that would support a reasonable fear that the petitioner faces persecution.” Id.
The Ninth Circuit has defined persecution as “the infliction of suffering or harm upon those who differ in race, religion, political opinion in a way regarded as offensive.” Ghaly v. INS, 58 F3.d 1425 (9th Cir. 1995).
Subjective Prong: Well-Founded Fear of Persecution
The subjective prong of the well-founded fear test is satisfied by an applicant’s credible testimony that he or she genuinely fears harm. See Ahmed, 503 F.3d at 1191; see also Lolong v. Gonzalez, 484 F.3d 1173, 1178-79 (9th Cir. 2007) (finding subjective fear where petitioner described fears and gave specific examples of violent incidents involved friends and family); Berroteran-Melendez v. INS, 955 F.2d 1251, 1257-58 (9th Cir. 1992) (Nicaraguan who failed to present candid, credible and sincere testimony demonstrating a genuine fear of persecution … failed to satisfy the subjective component of the well-founded fear standard).
Objective Prong
The objective prong of the well-founded fear analysis can be satisfied in two different ways: (1) one way to satisfy the objective component is to prove persecution in the past, giving rise to a rebuttable presumption that a well-founded fear of future persecution exists; (2) the second way is to show a good reason to fear future persecution by adducing credible, direct, and specific evidence in the record of facts that would support a reasonable fear of persecution. The objective requirement can be met either through the production of specific documentary evidence or by credible and persuasive testimony. Ladha v. INS, 215 F.3d 889, 887 (9th Cir. 2000).
A well-founded fear does not require certainty of persecution or even a probability of persecution. Hoxha v. Ashcroft, 319 F.3d 1179, 1184 (9th Cir. 2002). Even a ten percent chance of persecution may establish a well-founded fear. Al-Harbi v. INS, 242 F.3d 882, 888 (9th Cir. 2001). The court has stated that objective circumstances must be determined in the political, social, and cultural milieu of the place where the petitioner lived. Montecino v. INS, 915 F.2d 518, 520 (9th Cir. 1990).
Persecution + 5 Grounds + Objective and Subjective Reasonable Credible Fear of Future Persecution
Persecution from country of nationality unless stateless persecution = threat to the life or freedom of or the infliction of suffering or harm upon those who differ in a way regarded as offensive differs from harassment.
Persecution must involve significant physical force or barbaric conduct but permanent or serious injury is not required
· Rape, sexual assault, forced medical exams may be persecution but threats, physical harm or short-term detentions may not persecution may be emotional or psychological harassment – without more is not persecution.
What is not Persecution?
· Discrimination – It is not persecution except in extraordinary cases, so loss of work or economic opportunities is not persecution BUT- economic deprivation can be persecution if the deprivation is so severe that it constitutes a threat to life or freedom of the individual – including deprivation of liberty, food, housing, employment or other essentials of life.
· Conscription in the military is not per se persecution. There needs to be a nexus between the imputed or actual political opinion and the alleged persecution.
Five protected grounds – one of them MUST be ONE OF THE CENTRAL GROUNDS for persecution under REAL ID ACT
There are five grounds of persecution that account for a well-founded fear; race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. 8 U.S.C §1101(a)(42)(A).
The asylum seeker must establish a nexus between the enumerated ground and the persecution is not persecution unless motivated by one of the 5 enumerated factors:
· Race
· Religion
· National origin
· Political Opinion
o Neutrality as political opinion
o Imputed political opinion
· Social group
Mixed-Motive: At Least One Central Reason for Persecution
Applies to asylum and withholding: the enumerated ground was or will be at least one central reason for the persecution. This did away with the “at least in part” basis. The protected ground must be one principal motivation although it need not be 51% of the motivation. The 3rd circuit has said that there may be a hierarchy of motives where one may be subordinate to another.
Keep in mind that it is the applicant’s burden to prove that it is a central reason and to frame the hierarchy where appropriate.
The BIA and mixed-motive post REAL ID: addressed in Matter J-B-N & S-M, 24 I & N Dec. 208 (2007): one central reason – mixed motive can be established by testimonial evidence and by either direct or circumstantial evidence. The protected ground cannot be incidental, tangential, superficial or subordinate to any other reason for harm.
Bars: If the Respondent applicant gave a ransom to the supporting terrorist group, therefore not eligible now to get relief; also, if a bribe was offered for release from persecution/detention by Respondent- it creates a reason to deny Asylum application by the IJ or the officer.
Religion
Persecution based on religion may assume various forms. Examples could include prohibition of membership of a religious community, of worship in community with others in public or private, of religious instruction, or serious measures of discrimination imposed on individuals because they practice their religion, belong to or are identified with a particular religious community, or have changed their faith.” UNHCR Guidelines on International Protection: Religion-Based Refugee Claims under Article 1A (2) of the 1951 Convention and/or the 1967 Protocol relating to the Status of Refugees, April 28, 2004.
Guo v. Ashcroft, 361 F.3d 1194, 1203 (9th Cir. 2004) (Chinese Christian was persecuted on account of his religion when he was arrested, detained, physically abused, and forced to sign an affidavit renouncing his religion, after he participated in illegal religious activities and attempted to stop an officer from removing a cross from a tomb).
Political Opinion
An asylum applicant must satisfy two requirements in order to show that s/he was persecuted on account of a political opinion.
First, an applicant must show that he held (or that his persecutors believed that he held) a political opinion. Second, the applicant must show that his persecutors persecuted him (or that he faces the prospect of such persecution) because of his political opinion. Navas v. INS, 217 F.3d 646, 656 (9th Cir. 2000). An applicant must establish that the political opinion would motivate his potential prosecutors. Njuguna v. Ashcroft, 374 F.3d 765, 770 (9th Cir. 2004). An applicant may manifest his or her political opinion by membership or participation in an organization with political purposes or goals. Montoya-Ulloa v. INS, 79 F.3d 930, 931 (9th Cir. 1996).
Imputed Opinion
A political opinion can also be imputed to a person based on the people he or she associates with (or is associated with) – including friends, colleagues, neighbors, family members, and members of the person’s other social groups, or even mere acquaintances.
Applicant has a well-founded fear based on his imputed political opinion. To establish eligibility for asylum based on a well-founded fear of persecution it is the Applicant’s burden to establish: 1) S/he possess (or is believed to possess) beliefs or characteristics the persecutor seeks to overcome in another; 2) the persecutor is already aware, or could become aware, that s/he possesses these beliefs or characteristics; 3) the persecutor has the capability of persecuting the applicant; and 4) the persecutor has the inclination to persecute the applicant. See Matter of Mogharrabi, 19 I&N Dec. 439 (BIA 1987).
An imputed political opinion arises when “a persecutor falsely attributes an opinion to the victim, and then persecutes the victim because of that mistaken belief about the victim’s views.” Canas-Segovia, 970 F.2d at 602. Under the imputed political opinion doctrine, the applicant’s own opinions are irrelevant. See Hernandez-Ortiz v. INS, 777 F.2d 509, 517 (9th Cir. 1985). “Our analysis focuses on how the persecutor perceived the applicant’s actions and allegiances, and what motivated their abuse.” Agbuya v. INS, 241 F.3d 1224, 1229-30 (9th Cir. 2001).
Therefore, the Persecutor’s view of applicant’s actions is what matters – not how the applicant perceived his or her actions.
Proving persecution for imputed political opinion requires showing a causal link between one’s persecution and one’s persecutor’s beliefs and perceptions. This can be difficult, especially when persecutors do not explicitly describe the motivations behind their actions.
Social Group Membership for Basis of Asylum Claim
The phrase ‘particular social group’ is ambiguous. See Cordoba v. Holder, 726 F.3d 1106, 1114 (9th Cir. 2013). To determine whether a social group exists, the court considers certain factors, including “whether a group’s shared characteristics gives members social visibility and whether the group can be defined with sufficient particularity to delimit its membership.” Arteaga v. Mukasey, 511 F.3d 940, 944 (9th Cir. 2007).
A particular social group implies a collection of people closely affiliated with each other, who are actuated by some common impulse of interest. Sanchez-Trujillo v. INS, 801 F.2d 1571, 1576-77 (9th Cir. 1986). A particular social group is one united by a voluntary association, including a former association, or by an innate characteristic that is so fundamental to the identities or consciences of its members that members either cannot or should not be required to change it. Hernandez-Montiel v. INS, 225 F.3d 1084, 1092 (9th Cir. 2000).
Social Group Membership for Basis of Asylum Claim
United By a Voluntary Association or by an innate Characteristic that is so Fundamental to the identities or conscience of its members that members either cannot or should not be required to change it Social Visibility: Henriquez-Rivas v. Holder, 707 F.3d 1081 (9th Cir. 2013)
Social visibility does not require “on-sight” (naked eye) visibility but is rather some broader form of societal perception.
The essence of the particularity requirement is- whether a group can accurately be described in a manner sufficiently distinct that the group would be recognized in the society in question as a discrete class of persons.
EXAMPLES:
· Gender and Related Claims
· LGBT
· FGM
· Repressive Population Control
· Forced marriage
· Domestic Violence – still a work in progress
· Violence Against Women
See Trump government’s actions on ending Asylum eligibility for victims of DV in June 2018
Asylum Law Procedures
Real ID Act Effective Date: May 11, 2005
Changes in burden and standards of proof apply to applications made (filed) on or after 5/11/2005.
Applications filed with the Central Index Systems (CIS)before 5/11/2005 but referred to court after 5/11/2005 are not deemed under REAL ID.
Affirmative Asylum
To apply for asylum in the U.S., you must be physically present in the U.S.
1. Filing with USCIS– Referred to Immigration Court — Motion to Reopen
Defensive Asylum # 1: Applied Affirmatively but Referred to EOIR Court by USCIS
2. The applicant files for Asylum within one year of entry in the U.S. (Strict deadline with very limited exceptions discussed later).
3. After filing, the applicant waits for an interview with a USCIS officer to be scheduled.
4. The applicant can apply for a work permit after 6 months or 180 days of applying for Asylum, if no interview is scheduled by then.
5. The USCIS officer reviews affirmatively-filed Asylum applications and, if after the interview the applicant’s case is NOT approved, then it is referred to an EOIR court and an Immigration Judge.
6. The applicant is mailed/given a Notice to Appear/NTA. This will state that where and when the applicant must appear in court and point out the time and date on the NTA.
7. At the EOIR court, the Respondent, (who was the applicant at USCIS level) will have an opportunity to present his/her asylum case all over again, before the immigration court judge in a trial setting with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) attorney as the Opposing counsel.
8. The respondent is subject to cross examination and rules of admissibility.
9. If the Immigration Judge grants the Respondent Asylum- then Respondent can file for a green card after 1 years of the approval date. If denied….
Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) is the Next Body to Appeal the IJ’s Decision
If BIA denies the claims- then Respondent could go to federal district court from there onto Circuit court and ultimately to the Supreme Court of the United States if he has grounds for appealing the decisions of the IJ and BIA judge.
Defensive Asylum- Apprehended at the Border
Credible Fear Interview
Individuals apprehended by Customs and Border Protection at a port of entry without valid documentation or within 100 miles of the border in the first two weeks after crossing it without valid documentation may be put in expedited removal proceedings.
Individuals in expedited removal proceedings may not be allowed to appear before an Immigration Judge unless they express a fear of return to their home country. Such individuals will then be interviewed by an asylum officer to determine if the individual has a Credible Fear of persecution or torture in the individual’s native country.
Individuals found to have a “credible fear” of persecution or torture will have their cases referred to the Immigration Judge for full consideration of the individual’s request for Asylum, Withholding or CAT,
If the asylum officer decides during the credible fear interview that the individual does not have a credible fear of persecution or torture, the individual may request a review of this decision by an Immigration Judge.
Corroborating Claims of Applicant
Credibility
Adverse credibility finding may be based on any inaccuracies or falsehoods in the applicant’s statements without regard to whether they go to the heart of the claim
TOC for all relevant factors that, considered in light of the totality of the circumstances can reasonably be said to have a bearing on the applicant’s veracity Ren v. Holder, 9th Cir 2011, IJ may base an adverse credibility determination on any relevant factor that, considered in light of the totality of the circumstances can reasonably be said to have a bearing on the petitioner’s veracity.
Trivial inconsistencies that under the total circumstances have no bearing on a petitioner’s veracity should not form the basis of an adverse credibility determination. Adverse credibility findings must be supported by substantial evidence.
When Corroboration is Necessary
Testimony of applicant may be sufficient without corroboration if the testimony is credible, persuasive and sufficiently specific as to facts
The IJ must first determine whether the applicant has met his burden. If the IJ finds the applicant credible but is not persuaded, the trier of fact must provide the applicant with adequate notice and opportunity to provide evidence that corroborates otherwise credible testimony and the applicant should do so unless the applicant does not have the evidence and cannot reasonably obtain it.
Evidentiary Documents:
Authentication of Documents is governed by 8 CFR 287.6
USA docs: must be certified
Foreign: must be certified from government entity, and then must go to the foreign consulate of that country in the USA for authentication.
Documents must be translated with certification of translation with it.
Affidavits- Do not make it inadmissible but their absence undermines the weight of the evidence submitted.
Credible Fear Interview
Individuals apprehended by Customs and Border Protection at a port of entry without valid documentation or within 100 miles of the border in the first two weeks after crossing it without valid documentation may be put in expedited removal proceedings.
Individuals in expedited removal proceedings may not be allowed to appear before an Immigration Judge unless they express a fear of return to their home country. Such individuals will then be interviewed by an asylum officer to determine if the individual has a Credible Fear of persecution or torture in the individual’s native country.
Individuals found to have a “credible fear” of persecution or torture will have their cases referred to the Immigration Judge for full consideration of the individual’s request for Asylum, Withholding or CAT,
If the asylum officer decides during the credible fear interview that the individual does not have a credible fear of persecution or torture, the individual may request a review of this decision by an Immigration Judge.
Credible Fear Interview Details
Stowaways, crewmen and persons subject to expedited removal who seek asylum, withholding or CAT are given credible fear interviews by an Asylum Officer (AO) or someone who receives AO training.
The applicant may consult with an attorney at no cost to the government.
Credible fear is defined to mean that taking into account the credibility of the statements made by the alien in support of the alien’s claim and such other facts as are known to the interviewing USCIS officer or immigration judge, there is a significant possibility that the aliencouldestablisheligibilityforasylum,withholdingorCAT.MortonMemoDec8,2009.
A significant possibility must be more than a minimal or mere possibility or no possibility that generally requires that the applicant demonstrate a substantial and realistic possibility of succeeding. Lafferty Memo.
In addition to determining the possibility for asylum, the AO must also determine whether there is a credible fear of torture. The OA must consider all elements of CAT, including custodyandcontrol,lawfulsanctions,specificintenttoinflictseverephysicalormentalpain or suffering when mental pain and suffering constitute torture, public official action and acquiescence and internal location.
If the alien establishes credible fear to the asylum officer and establishes to ICE satisfaction of his or her identity, the likelihood that she will appear for all hearings and enforcement appointments, and that she is not a security risk, she may be paroled.
If alien is not found by the AO to have a credible fear, she may request a review before the Immigration Judge. DHS issues an I-863 which limits the IJ’s jurisdiction to review of the credible fear determination. Review must be made within 7 days and the applicant is detained until the credible fear determination is made. If IJ finds credible fear, applicant is placed into removal proceedings unless they are a stowaway. Then asylum only hearing. If no credible fear is found, applicant is detained until removal. There is no appeal of the credible fear determination by the AO or IJ but applicant may make one last credible fear claim before removal
Withholding of Removal/Convention Against Torture
Arriving aliens claiming credible fear may also seek withholding of removal or relief under Article 3 of the Convention Against Torture.
Withholding and CAT differ from asylum in that asylum results in lawful status and can lead to green card.
Withholding or CAT are granted in conjunction with a removal order and do not lead to any lawful status (although one may live in US indefinitely and may receive an EAD).
Withholding requires a showing that it is more likely than not that alien will be subject to persecution under one of the 5 enumerated grounds (race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group or political opinion) if they are returned home.
CAT requires a showing that, if returned home, the applicant will be subject to torture either by the government or with the acquiescence of the government. The cause of the torture need not be based on an enumerated ground.
Upon a showing of credible fear, may be eligible for bond or parole.
One-Year Bar Rule – IIRIRA
Asylum must be filed within ONE year of the arrival of the foreign national in the United States.
Exceptions to the one-year rule:
· Applicant was in status.
This is an ok reason for not filing for asylum. You can file after losing status within a reasonable time, not any more than 6 months (in the regulations)! You can make arguments why more than 6 months is not unreasonable.
· Changed Circumstances 8 CFR 208.4(a)(4)(i); 1208.4(a)(4)(i)(A) circumstances that materially affect the applicant’s eligibility for asylum these include:
o change in nationality
o change in US law
o change in applicant’s activities outside home country that place him at risk
o change in personal circumstances including having aged-out or divorced
· Extraordinary Circumstances 8 CFR 208.4(a)(4)(i); 1208.4(a)(4)(i)(A) relates to events or factors that directly relate to the failure to file within the year the applicant must demonstrate that the circumstance was not intentionally created through the action or inaction of the applicant the circumstance directly related to the failure to file within the year the delay was reasonable under the circumstances
· Serious physical or mental illness – including those resulting from the persecution
· Legal disability (minor, incapacity)
IAC – Immigration Advisory Committee
· TPS, non-immigrant or immigrant status, parole
Timely filed but CIS rejected and refiled within a reasonable time.
· Death or serious illness or incapacity of the representative or immediate family member
The evidence does not need to be clear and convincing. The application must be filed within a reasonable time under the circumstances.
· Applications filed Before April 1, 1997
· Unaccompanied Minors
Relief Using Convention Against Torture (CAT)
The relief based on Convention Against Torture (CAT) is based on 8 C.F.R. §§ 208.16-18.
Like Withholding from Removal, it is a mandatory form of relief. Also, like Withholding from Removal and unlike Asylum, it can be filed at any time. Unlike Asylum and Withholding from Removal, it does not involve the 5 enumerated categories (religion, political, etc.). The Standard of Proof used to judge the case requires that the chance of torture be 51% or over. The relief granted is for individuals only (no relatives) and it comes in the form of a Withholding from Removal or deferral of removal. The relief granted comes with no travel privileges. If one should leave the USA, would be unlikely to be permitted to enter as, by leaving, one enacts the deportation order.
Returning Deportees
A person subject to reinstatement of removal orders retains the right to seek withholding of removal and CAT but not asylum or other relief.
If s/he establishes a reasonable fear of return, s/he will be referred to an IJ by the USCIS officer. The alien may also initiate a constitutional or legal challenge to the original removal proceedings.
Reinstatement- Returning Deportees
When a non-citizen reenters the U.S. illegally after being removed or given VD under an order of removal, DHS can reinstate the prior order of removal. The alien cannot seek to reopen the original order, review the reinstated order or seek relief from removal. To reinstate, DHS must ascertain whether the person has been subject to a prior order of removal, whether the non-citizen is the same person who was previously removed and whether the person unlawfully reentered the U.S. The statute includes exclusion, deportation and removal proceedings as well as expedited and stipulated removal orders. An illegal reenter can include entry by use of a false identification document. It may also include entry that is procedurally legal but not otherwise legal due to the prior removal order. Entry can be “otherwise illegal” due to having failed to obtain advance permission to reapply for admission. There is no right to a hearing before an Immigration Judge.
A person subject to reinstatement retains the right to seek withholding of removal and CAT but not asylum or other relief. If s/he establishes a reasonable fear of return, s/he will be referred to an IJ by the USCIS officer. The alien may also initiate a constitutional or legal challenge to the original removal proceedings.
Reasonable Fear Interviews- Returning Deportees
A person subject to expedited removal or reinstatement of a removal order who expresses fear of returning to the country of removal will be given a reasonable fear interview by an administrative officer (AO).
The interview is conducted in a non-adversarial manner and the applicant may be represented by counsel at no cost to the government. Without any reference to any bars to eligibility, the AO determines whether there is a reasonable possibility that the person would be persecuted or a reasonable possibility that s/he would be tortured in the country of removal. The interview and determination are supposed to be made within 10 days but they generally take much longer than that. The AO does not consider the case referred to it until it has received the notice that a person requires a reasonable fear screening, the completed reinstatement decision (I-871) or Final Administrative Order (I-851A) and the A file. Kim Memo.
If an applicant is found to have a reasonable fear, s/he will be referred to an Immigration Judge (IJ) for consideration of withholding or CAT.
If the applicant is not found to have a reasonable fear, s/he may seek IJ review of the AO’s decision of no reasonable fear. If the Immigration Judge IJ agrees, the case is returned to ICE for the applicant’s removal. There is no appeal. If the IJ finds reasonable fear, the applicant can file an I-589 for consideration by the IJ.
Immigration Court and Relief from Removal
Overview
EOIR Hearings: Administrative hearing held by the Executive Office of Immigration Review to apply the laws of immigration fairly, judiciously and uniformly. Can result in deportation.
Notice to Appear (NTA)- Form I-862
The first step in removal proceedings is the serving of the charging document, the Notice to Appear. This could be issued by one of the following agencies within the Department of Homeland Security (DHS): Immigration and Custom’s Enforcement (ICE), United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) or Customs and Border Protection (CBP).
Service of NTA
The NTA is served in person or via mail (mail presumption it as mailed to correct address if no AR-11 on file). Minors cannot be served- the person that the minor is in custody of will be served with the NTA.
It is important to review the NTA for accuracy and to challenge it if it is inaccurate.
Motions
MOTION TO CHANGE VENUE: EOIR court will be where Respondent was apprehended- this can be changed dispensing on where the Respondent moved to later/after release.
In absentia Orders- order removed where Respondent failed to appear at EOIR hearing even after given a warning of the consequences of doing so by an IJ. These can be appealed via Motion to Re-open within 180 days of the Order being issued.
Master Calendar
A brief hearing for status. The Immigration Judge takes information of the Respondent and this is where the Respondent will plead and state a form of relief that he intends to apply for. A date is then set for an individual hearing.
Determining Immigration Status
FOIA: G-639 Freedom of Information Act/Privacy Act Request
A FOIA request allows practitioners to retrieve an applicant’s full immigration case file history from USCIS. USCIS will collect information from the other agencies within DHS.
Voluntary departure
Permission for foreign national (FN) to depart (not at the government’s expense) within a specified time frame (if no immigration relief is available) at the conclusion of the merits hearing VD may be granted at the discretion of the IJ.
Individual Hearing
Merits hearings- trial setting- where IJ determines whether or not FN has a right to an immigration relief such as Asylum.
Follow the OCIJ Practice manual for guidance on how to submits evidentiary documents/supporting documents for the individual hearing to the court.
Trial procedures
Examination in Chief: allows FN to lay foundations for pertinent facts of the case through his/her direct testimony.
Cross Examination: by the DHS counsel -questions the FN on the stand in order the ascertain the veracity of the facts he testified to in his direct examination.
Evidence rules
FRE are applicable in EOIR settings but are very relaxed e.g. Hearsay is admissible
Expedited Removal
ICE can place a FN in Expedited Removal (ER) if:
· At entry there is fraud or misrepresentation when caught
· Arriving aliens at the border only are eligible to see an Immigration Judge if they pass the Credible Fear Interview (CFI) see Asylum
· 100 miles Jx rule- if apprehended within 100 miles of the US border can be placed in Expedited Removal.
If subject to ER the arriving alien is also subject to mandatory detention i.e. no bond available for these individuals.
Detention
When an arriving alien is found inadmissible at the POE, he or subject to detention. Bond factors include:
- Family and community ties in the US
- Whether the foreign national is likely to appear in any immigration court hearing scheduled to determine his or her removability
- Medical need
- Prior immigration history
- Length of time in the USA
- The person’s criminal and character history
- Whether there is any immigration relief available and what type
Mandatory Detention
For final order of removal, see INA §241.
Order of supervision: release from ICE detention on terms such as reporting to ICE regularly or ankle monitor.
- Those inadmissible for committing two or more crimes involving moral turpitude
- Those deportable for multiple criminal convictions
- Those deportable for convictions involving controlled substances
- Those inadmissible or deportable for security related grounds
- Those deportable for certain firearms offenses and
- Those deportable for miscellaneous crimes
Prosecutorial Discretion
Prosecutorial discretion can be used to prevent the removal of them who have sympathetic factors such as those listed below. However, it does not confer immigration status or rant the ability to obtain permission to work. Prosecutorial factors include:
- Whether the person or the person’s spouse suffers from severe mental illness
- Whether the person has a USC spouse, child or parent
- A person’s criminal history
- Whether the person has served in the US military, reserves, or national guard, with particular consideration given to those who served in combat.
- A person’s immigration history, etc.
Relief In Removal: Adjustment of Status and Asylum
Adjustment of Status
One can apply for adjustment of status while in removal, using an I-130 and I485. However, if one is applying based on a spousal petition, extra scrutiny will be placed on the spousal relationship such that persuasive evidence is required that the marriage is bona fide.
Asylum
NON-LPRS- Must apply within one year of entry into the US.
LPRs can apply after losing status- because before they were in status! Until the LPR status is ripped off finally, they can always re-apply. They are still LPR even if in removal- if taken your GC away- can file for a I-551 and will get it. even if denied- up to 9th Cir- they are still LPRs.
Relief In Removal: Adjustment of Status and Asylum
Adjustment of Status
One can apply for adjustment of status while in removal, using an I-130 and I485. However, if one is applying based on a spousal petition, extra scrutiny will be placed on the spousal relationship such that persuasive evidence is required that the marriage is bona fide.
Asylum
NON-LPRS- Must apply within one year of entry into the US.
LPRs can apply after losing status- because before they were in status! Until the LPR status is ripped off finally, they can always re-apply. They are still LPR even if in removal- if taken your GC away- can file for a I-551 and will get it. even if denied- up to 9th Cir- they are still LPRs.
Cancellation of Removal (COR)
(LPR v. Non-LPR)
LPR INA §240A(A): Cancellation is available for any LPR who
· Has been an LPR for not less than five years;
· Has resided in the United States continuously for not less than seven years in any status; and
· Has not been convicted of an aggravated felony.
There are discretionary factors that can affect success:
- Family ties within the US (such that it would be a hardship if the LPR were to depart)
- A history of employment
- The existence of property or business ties
- Long standing residence in the US, particularly if begun at an early age
- Service in the Armed Forces of the US
- The existence of property or business ties
- Evidence of value and service to the community
- Proof of genuine rehabilitation if a criminal record exists
- Evidence attesting to the respondent’s good character
NON LPRS (both NIV AND EWI’S) INA §240A(B): Cancellation of Removal is available for aliens of any immigration status who
· Has 10 years continuously residing in the United States;
· Has been a person of good moral character (GMC) throughout this time;
· Has a qualifying relative who is either a U.S. citizen or LPR parent, spouse, or child;
· Has not been convicted of certain crimes, such as those that are inadmissible or deportable, those that persecute others, etc. (However, there is no criminal bar arising from a conviction of any crime outlined in INA §212(a)(2), §237(a)(2), or §237(a)(3));
Finally, to succeed, the respondent must prove that removal would result in “exceptional and extremely unusual hardship” to the alien’s spouse, parent, or child who is a USC or LPR.
Continuous Presence for Cancellation of Removal (COR)
Absences from the US cannot exceed 90 days during one trip or more than 180 days in aggregate through the 7 or 10-years-time rule for COR.
LPR Vs. Non-LPR COR
The Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
VAWA cancellation of removal is a form of relief designed to keep victims of abusive U.S.-citizen or LPR spouses or parents from being deported. It is a form of relief that a noncitizen victim can seek in immigration court after being placed in removal proceedings. Successful cancellation of removal results in LPR status for the victim, and his or her noncitizen children ultimately receive a green card as well.
To qualify for VAWA cancellation of removal, a victim must prove:
· That he or she has been battered or subjected to extreme cruelty by a U.S.-citizen or LPR spouse or parent.
· Physical presence in the United States for 3 years.
· Good moral character.
· That removal would cause extreme hardship.
· That certain inadmissibility grounds do not apply or that she qualifies for a waiver of inadmissibility.
NACARA- Nicaraguan Adjustment and Central American Relief Act
Section 203 of NACARA allows qualified individuals to apply for suspension of deportation or for cancellation of removal (“NACARA 203 relief”) under the standards similar to those in effect before the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act (IIRIRA) of 1996. Before 1996, cancellation of removal was called suspension of removal.
Requirements:
· To not be inadmissible under section 212(a)(2) or (3) or deportable under section 237(a)(2), 3, or 4 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (relating to certain criminal activity, document fraud, failure to register, and security threats);
· To have been continuously physically present in the United States for 7 years immediately preceding the filing of the application;
· To have been a person of good moral character (GMC) for the 7 year statutory period;
· To demonstrate that removal would result in extreme hardship to the alien, or to the alien’s spouse, parent, or child who is either a U.S. citizen (USC) or lawful permanent resident (LPR).
Naturalization and Citizenship
Naturalization
Citizenship and Naturalization
INTRODUCTION
Citizenship is a unique bond that unites people around civic ideals and a belief in the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.
Deciding to become a U.S. citizen is one of the most important decisions an immigrant can make. Depending on your situation, there may be different ways to obtain citizenship.
- Naturalizationis the process by which U.S. citizenship is granted to a lawful permanent resident after meeting the requirements established by Congress in the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA).
- Acquisition of citizenship is obtained through U.S. citizenship parents either at birth or after birth, but before the age of 18.
Explore the links below to help you determine what applies to you. Depending on your situation, there may be other requirements that you must fulfill.
- I am a Lawful Permanent Resident of 5 Years
- I am Married to a U.S. Citizen
- I am Serving in the U.S. Military
- I am the Child of a U.S. Citizen
Also, visit our Citizenship for Military Family Members page.
For more information, see the USCIS Policy Manual Citizenship and Naturalization Guidance.
Additional Resources
Naturalization is the process of becoming a citizen. It has many basic requirements and is generally achieved using the N-400, Application for Naturalization.
Basic Requirements:
- 18 years of age
- Residency requirement – 5 years Lawful Permanent Resident (LPR)
- 5 years U.S. residency
- Physically present at least 30 months in last five years
- Lived at least 3 months in USCIS district in which applying
- Good moral character
- Attachment to principles and ideals of U.S. Constitution
- Read, write & speak basic English (tested by an exam)
- Basic knowledge of U.S. history and government (tested by an exam)
- Take oath of allegiance
- Draft evaders ineligible
Residency Requirement: Five Years as a Lawful Permanent Resident
Residency starts the day LPR status is granted and must run a minimum of 5 years. (But you can apply 90 days before 5th year anniversary of winning LPR status.) There are two exceptions to the 5-year LPR requirement.
The first exception involves cases of being married to a US Citizen spouse for 3 years, such that: (1) the spouse has been a USC for 3 years; and (2) the candidate has been legitimately married for 3 years.
The second exception involves a battered Spouse/Child, one who has become a lawful permanent resident via the Violence Against Women Act VAWA (by USC). In this case, the three-year marriage requirement is waived and children are included, but they must be 18 years of age to naturalize.
5 Years Residency in a 5-Year Cycle as a Green Card Holder
You have to be careful of your absences from the United States during your 5 years of residency. An absence of greater than 6 months raises a presumption of interruption. An absence greater than 1 year raises presumption of abandonment. There are some exceptions to these limitations on absences. For example, if you are out of the US for Military Service, with advanced permission (N-470), or for work or school abroad.
Good Moral Character for 5 Years- § INA 101(f)
One requirement is that you demonstrate having had good moral character for the last 5 years. This means that you have avoided the following:
- Being a habitual drunkard
- Committing crimes: Crimes outside a 5-year (or 3-year) period are discretionary
- Polygamy
- Prostitution
- Smuggling
- Crimes of Moral Turpitude
- Drug crimes (except <30 grams of MJ)
- Aggravated felony (anytime after 11/29/1990)
- Convicted of 2 or more gambling offenses
- Crimes that don’t make you deportable (e.g. domestic violence)
- Having income principally from illegal gambling
- Giving false testimony
- Assisting with Nazi persecution
- Making a false claim to citizenship
- Voting unlawfully
Discretionary Determination: Can still be found not to have GMC
There are other factors that can inhibit one’s ability to become a citizen. For example, if one has been found not to support one’s dependents, this is a strike against citizenship. Or if you have committed adultery, that is a strike against citizenship.
Medical or Disability Waiver – N-648
Some people are unable to pass either the English exam or the exam of basic US history because of physical or mental limitations. Some of those people may qualify for the medical waiver, the N-648. In the N-648 form the reviewing physician, who must be a civil surgeon, reviews and evaluates the mental abilities of the patient. Then a sealed copy is given to the patient to put in their application for citizenship packet.
Process: Completing an Application for Naturalization
Once you have met the basic requirements for Naturalization, it’s time to assemble your application. In it should go the following forms and documents:
- Form G-28, Notice of Appearance of Entry as Attorney or Accredited Representative, if the client is employing an attorney
- Form I-912, Request for Fee Waiver or Copy of Filing Fee check made out to the Department of Homeland Security
- Form N-400, Application for Naturalization
- Copy of birth certificate of applicant
- Copy (front and back) of Lawful Permanent Resident card
- Copy of biographic page of passport
- Form N-648 Medical Certification of Disability Exceptions, for those who, due to a physical or mental disability, are unable to take the English and Civics exam
- If you are basing your application on your 3-year marriage to a US citizen, a copy of your marriage certificate and evidence of your spouse’s citizenship. If either party had married before, provide evidence of the termination of the prior marriage, so as to show the couple’s marriage is legitimate.
- If you have a criminal record, include certified dispositions for each and every arrest
- If you are applying for citizenship based on service in the armed forces Form N-426, Request for Certification of Military or Naval Service,
- Two passport style photos (with name, A# and birth date on the back) in an envelope labeled with the applicant’s name, A# and birthdate
If someone is missing documents at the time of the interview or fails the English or Civics exam, s/he may be given another chance in a process called re-examination. If the person is unable to pass the exam, they might want to consider getting a Form N-648.
Derivatives (INA 320)
Children may acquire citizenship at birth (for example, just by being born on American soil), or they may attain citizenship after birth through a derivative method. Being born to one (or two) USC parents can be one way to become a US citizen. Depending on when the person was born, different rules apply concerning whether it is a requirement for only one parent to have naturalized or both. If you are born after the Child Citizenship Act of February 27, 2001, only one parent has to be naturalized to confer the citizen benefit.
As long as a person meets all the requirements of citizenship before 18, he or she can attain citizenship through their parents. The process for deriving citizenship through the parents requires the use of the N-600. If you take this route, rather than going through the green card and naturalization process, you don’t have to prove Good Moral Character.
Another way for a child to naturalize is to be under 18 years old, a legal permanent resident, and in the legal and physical custody of a parent who goes through the naturalization process. When the parent becomes naturalized, so does the child.
Inadmissibility, Deportation and Waivers
• Inadmissibility and Deportation
• Waivers
Inadmissibility, Deportation and Waivers
1. Inadmissibility and Deportation
Admissibility
To enter the US with any status, or to adjust or change status, an individual must be admissible to the United States. Admissibility begins with lawful entry of a foreign national into the US, after inspection and authorization by a US Immigration Officer.
Four Scenarios of Seeking Admissions
Example: 1: One way to gain admissibility into the US is by seeking and obtaining a consular visa, and then seeking admission at the Port-of-Entry (POE).
Example: 2: Admissibility is assessed again at the POE, where the CBP officer will again review how long the foreign national will be allowed to stay.
Example: 3: Suppose that, after entering the US on a nonimmigrant visa, the foreign national falls in love with a US citizen (USC) and gets married. Suppose further that the USC spouse petitions and files an Adjustment of Status. In this case should the foreign national be awarded Lawful Permanent Status they would also be granted admission, even though they are already within the US? In other words, a change of status is also known as an admission. §245(a)
Example: 4: Admissions in removal in front of an immigration judge.
A Lawful Permanent Resident (LPR) …
Has to seek admission when they re-enter if they:
- formerly abandoned the LPR status;
- were absent for more than 180 continuous days;
- engaged in illegal activity after leaving country;
- have previously committed a crime under §212(a)(2) w/o being a granted a waiver under 212(h) or relief in form of §240(a), and this is the first time they have left the country since the crime.
Deportation
An Immigration Judge (IJ) in an administrative hearing can order an alien or a Legal Permanent Resident (LPR) to be ordered removed from the US on several grounds. This is done with a Notice to Appear (NTA).
Grounds of Inadmissibility
- Health related Grounds (INA §212(a)(1))
- Drug Abusers/Addict – straight out inadmissible
- No waiver for people seeking an IV. However other aliens can seek the general §212(d)(3) waiver.
- Communicable Diseases: Public Health significance by HHS
- Waiver (§212(g)(1): Spouse, son, daughter, child of USC, LPR or IV holder
- Vaccinations: Preventable diseases
- Waiver (§212(g)(2): 1) No documents to prove; 2) not medically appropriate; 3) religious/moral convictions
- These do not apply to refugees and asylees.
- Physical/Mental Disorder: Threat to property, safety & welfare
- Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude (INA §212(a)(2)(A)(i)(I))
- Persons Likely to Be Public Charge (INA §212(a)(4))
- Poverty Guidelines & Affidavit of Support (I-864). As part of the application process there must be evidence that the person supporting the would-be immigrant makes at least 125% of the poverty level, and there must be an affidavit of support.
- If individuals are required to submit a change of address form (such as those with green cards and pending applications), if they do not submit the change of address form within 10 days, they become deportable, though this is rarely enforced. Also, the foreign national can provide evidence that the oversight was not willful.
- Someone who presents false documents is inadmissible.
- Public charge: The would-be immigrant must not go on public benefits until after 5 years after becoming a Lawful Permanent Resident.
212 (a)(3) Security Related Exception
If someone can show that the activities that they engaged in that make them potentially inadmissible were performed under duress, USCIS might make an exception.
Illegal Reentry (Often after Deportation) and Parole
To parole a foreign national means to grant them permission to enter the US, despite their lack of eligibility, under the legal fiction that they are still standing at the Port-of- Entry (POE) waiting for a decision to be made whether or not they are eligible to adjust their status or to be admitted in certain immigrant visa categories. INA §245 (i)
Prior Immigration Violations – 04-01-1997 — §212(a)(9) A, B and C
§212(a)(9)(A)
Unlawful Presence
§212(a)(9)(A): Physically returned or removed/deported without attorney at EOIR or the border or is still here but has an order of removal §212 (a)(9)- Unlawful presence is the period of time when you are in the United States without being admitted or paroled or when you are not in a “period of stay authorized by the Secretary.” You may be barred from reentering the United States:
- Permanently, if you reenter or try to reenter the United States without being admitted or paroled after having accrued more than one year of unlawful presence in the aggregate during one or more stays in the United States.
If you are an alien and you are not a lawful permanent resident of the United States, you may be inadmissible forever under INA 212(a)(9)(C)(i)(I) if:
- You accrued an aggregate period of more than 1 year of unlawful presence in the United States on or after April 1, 1997, and then departed the United States or were removed from the United States; and
- You entered or attempted to reenter the United States on or after April 1, 1997, without a DHS officer admitting or paroling you into the United States.
“Aggregate period” means the total number of days of unlawful presence that you accumulated during all of your stays in the United States combined.
Arriving aliens: 5 years outside the US- 20 years if a removal order or aggravated felony
Other aliens: 10 years outside the US- 20 years if a removal order or aggravated felony
§212 (a)(9)(A) Exception
The only available exceptions at this time have to do with timing, given that this section of the law went into effect on April 1, 1997. First, people who last reentered the U.S. before April 1, 1997 after a previous deportation are not subject to the permanent bar. Second, people who accrued unlawful presence before April 1, 1997 need not count this time towards the aggregate one year needed to trigger the permanent bar.
§212 (a)(9)(a) Relief?
The statute says that someone subject to the permanent bar can request permission to enter the U.S. after waiting ten years first. Seek I- 212 Permission to re-enter.
You can get an I-212 Waiver after 20 years, for people removed because of Crimes of Moral Turpitude or aggravated felony. It might be grounds to challenge the removal order- e.g. if there were no counsel.
If the order is from 15 years ago- see new developments of case law and new interpretations of case law now. Consider the challenge to validity of underlying removal order. Consider changes in case law such that a prior conviction may no longer be an aggravated felony. You risk a reinstatement of removal. You can be removed very fast.
The 3 and 10-Year BARS for Unlawful Presence (ULP) 04/01/1997 (INA §212(a)(9)(B))
Unlawful presence is the period of time when you are in the United States without being admitted or paroled or when you are not in a “period of stay authorized by the Secretary.”
You may be barred from reentering the United States for:
- 3 years, if you depart the United States after having accrued more than 180 days but less than 1 year of unlawful presence during a single stay and before the commencement of removal proceedings;
- 10 years, if you depart the United States after having accrued one year or more of unlawful presence during a single stay, regardless of whether you leave before, during, or after removal proceedings;
The bars are only triggered if the person departs from the country. There is a waiver that can be applied for waiving inadmissibility due to overstay using the Form 601A, which must involve qualifying relatives, either a spouse or parents. If a foreign national in removal proceedings opts for voluntary departure, the unlawful presence bar is not triggered. For students (F1), ULP does not begin to accrue until USCIS/ICE determines a violation has occurred.
Exceptions to Unlawful Presence (212 a 9 B): Exceptions for Not Accumulating ULP for the B Bar: (These Do Not Apply to 212 C Bar.)
- Minors- no ULP accumulated until age 18
- T-visa victims
- Battery victims – not subject to ULP bar
Tolling for good cause: lawful admitted + filed for extension or change of status + no unauthorized employment = 120 days maximum.
***COS*** tolls unlawful presence for 120 days from expiration of your lawful status student on &&F-1 stops going to school- remain ULP for 5 years= stays here. The B bar does not kick in (3/10 bar) but 248 (COS) requires you to maintain status to change your status. There is an exception to this. If you are changing status through an Immediate Relative, you can still change status even if you’ve accumulated unlawful presence. &&
Compare to: 212 A 9 C- permanent bar- deportation and more than a year of unlawful presence- tried EWI/unlawfully – C bar triggers&&
The main relief for a 3 to 10-year bar triggered by unlawful presence is the 600 or 601a Waiver. In the application, you have to show extreme hardship to a Qualifying Relative who is a United States Citizen or a Lawful Permanent Resident who is also a spouse or parent (not child) of the foreign national.
If the foreign national is in the USA, she or he can file for the 601A provisional waiver because they are going to do consular processing filed within the USA, with notice to NVC.
Permanent Bar: Unlawful Presence after Previous Violation: (INA §212(a)(9)(C))
- 1-year ULP or removal order + illegal entry = 10-year bar
- Cannot return – must leave for 10 years
- Waiver after 10 years of spending time outside the US
The permanent bar is being applied to children! If child travels back and forth as Entered Without Inspection (EWI) and then finally is petitioned for and applies for a green card, with a 601 waiver, they can be subject to the permanent bar!
There are two exceptions to the permanent bar:
- Attorney General consent after 10 years outside U.S.
- Battery Victim plus connection with violation
Deportation Grounds- INA §237
The foreign national is inadmissible at the time of entry (a)(1) if they are:
- Inadmissible at the time of entry or adjustment of status to a permanent relative
- Is present in the USA in violation of the law
- Fails to maintain the status in which they were admitted
- Has had terminated any conditional permanent resident status
- Knowingly encourage, induced, assisted, abetted or aided any other foreign national to enter or attempt to enter the United States other than an immediate relative of a person eligible for benefits under the Immigration Act 1990 §301(a), the [foreign national] smuggling provision
- Has procured a visa or other documentation through marriage fraud.
General Crimes §237(a)(2)(a)
General crimes include:
- One crime involving moral turpitude, committed with 5 years of admission to the US, a crime with the potential of sentence of confinement of 1 year or more
- Two CIMTs, nor arising out of a single scheme of criminal misconduct
- An aggravated felony crime
- High speed flight from law enforcement/immigration officials
- Failure to register as a sex offender
Criminal Grounds- Removal and Relief
Criminal Grounds of Removability
CPC § 1016.5 – requires the Judge to recite generic statutory language admonishing about possible immigration consequences, but not the actual consequences. (Padilla v. Kentucky)
Definition of Conviction:
For immigration purposes a sentence of 1 year makes a crime a deportable offense (time served plus probation counts together). This is determined by a Judge or jury verdict, a nolo contender or admission of guilt AND punishment (penalty/restraint on liberty imposed) in any form was ordered by judge.
Inadmissible Crimes
Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude (CIMTs)
(INA §212(a)(2)(A)(i)(I))
Crimes involving moral turpitude can concern convicted or admitted actions. Such actions are inherently base, vile or depraved and contrary to the accepted rules of morality in general, not dependent solely on being a felony or misdemeanor. They break down into crimes against a person, crimes against property, sexual and family crimes, and crimes against the authority of the government.
For Crimes of Moral Turpitude, see:
https: //fam.state.gov/fam/09FAM/09FAM030203.html #M302_3_2_B_2
- Fraud – theft- drug trafficking = always a CIMT
- Admissions to essential elements of the crime= CIMT (free)
- Foreign convictions and plea bargains included
- Conviction IS NOT required (just committing or admissions to committing a CIMT= makes person inadmissible!)
Exceptions to Crimes of Moral Turpitude: CIMT
There are the following exceptions:
- Purely political offense
- Juvenile delinquency disposition: Under 18 and more than 5 years lapsed
- Petty crime exception: misdemeanor, maximum possible penalty not to exceed 1 year and sentenced to less than 6 months
Illegal Drugs (Controlled Substances)
California law does not trump immigration law. Thirty grams of marijuana or less anything over is a removable offense.
Deportable Crimes §237(a)(2)(a)
- General crimes §237(a)(2)(A)
- Crimes of Moral Turpitude: CIMTs
- Aggravated Felony
- Flight from law enforcement
- Failure to register as a sex offender
- Domestic Violence (DV) §237(a)(2)(e) As of 9/30/1996: DV is a deportable offense. There is no waiver for it.
- Firearms §237 (a)(2)(C) are a special case. They are a deportable offense but not a ground of inadmissibility.
Aggravated Felony
It is defined at INA § 101(a)(43), 8 USC 1001(a)(43) and includes:
- Drug Trafficking – regardless of sentence
- Crimes of Violence (with a minimum 1-year sentence in imposed)
- Crimes involving Theft (with a minimum 1-year sentence imposed)
- Fraud with loss of $10,000 or more – no matter what the sentence
- Felon in possession of firearm
- Sexual abuse of minor, rape, murder
Aggravated felonies are the WORST. They usually result in becoming deportable with NO Form of Relief. Waivers do not apply to aggravated felonies like they do to CIMTs.
Categorical Approach (into a Federal Crime Statute)
When someone is convicted for an action under a state law statute (as a crime), it needs to be compared to the federal law matching that crime definition. If it does NOT fit into a federal statute categorically (if there is not a 100% match), it does not become an issue for immigration purposes. State statute elements must match the federal statute’s offense elements. If they do, the crime is deportable. If they do not, then there is a chance to fight deportation, arguing it’s not a deportable offense under federal law.
Modified Categorical Approach (MCA):
If state statute punishes conduct overbroadly, the categorical approach is applied.
If a state statue offense is divisible into 2 or more alternative offenses, then the Court will apply MCA- to see which of these alternatives was the offense of conviction and whether that offense matched the federal statue.
Removal of Conditions (ROC)- may contain information to identify the offense of conviction- can be used to identify the elements of the offense. It does not include police report. If ROC is conclusive- identify the offense of conviction. The client can use it to compare the elements with the Federal statute.
- Plea
- Sentencing documents
- Record of the verdict
Avoiding an Aggravated Felony is Often NOT Enough.
Determining Eligibility for Relief where there is no aggravated felony is very FACT specific, and you need to know:
- Years in the USA with a green card
- Years in the USA in another legal status
- Manner of entry
- Which relatives have lawful status
- Prior criminal record
- Prior immigration history
- Whether the individual has a valid fear of return to their home country, whether he or she is a person in non-immigrant visa status – if so, have they violated that status and many other factors …
Attempt to Mitigate Immigration Consequences of Criminal Activity Through:
- Diversion programs
- An immigration safe plea
- Suggesting an alternative plea to DA
- Being creative about sentencing
Inadmissibility v. Deportability
Being admissible is not the same thing as being deportable. Conditions for being Inadmissible falls under INA § 212 and being deportable falls under INA § 237.
Non-Immigrant Visa Waiver
The waiver allows an NIV applicant to overcome the grounds of inadmissibility and be granted a NIV visa. It is adjudicated at the Consulate abroad. If the consular officer recommends the Waiver for approval- the case is sent to Admissibility Review Office in Washington D.C. for a final decision.
The Hranka Waiver
The Hranka Waiver INA §212(d)(3) is an immigration court case- Matter of Hranka. It dictates the sets of 3 factors that immigration authorities must consider when deciding whether to grant the waiver:
1. the risk of harm to society if a waiver applicant is admitted to the U.S
2. the seriousness of an applicant’s prior criminal or immigration violations, if any, and
3. the nature of the applicant’s reason for wishing to enter the U.S.
212(h) Waiver for Crimes of Moral Turpitude (CIMTs)
You must look for the following elements:
- Time-Lapse Waiver
- 15 years lapsed since inadmissible event
- Admission not contrary to national welfare, safety of security
- Rehabilitation
- Hardship Waiver- denying waiver Extreme Hardship to USC/LPR Spouse, child or parent
- Foreign national is a VAWA Self-Petitioner
212(i) Fraud
212(i) Waiver for Fraud: Extreme hardship to USC/LPR spouse or parent
Waiver: Discretionary NIV Grant (212(d)(3))
When trying to get a nonimmigrant visa, fraud/crime renders the foreign national inadmissible. This statute allows the waiver of some crimes, and many other things (such as overstaying a visa), using Form I-192, Application for Advance Permission to Enter as A Nonimmigrant.
When evaluating people for this waiver (called the Hranka waiver), it’s important:
- how serious the acts were that caused the foreign national to be inadmissible (does NOT waive espionage/sabotage, or terrorism/ genocide).
- the risks of admitting the foreign national to the USA, and
- the reasons the foreign national has for wanting to enter the United States (must demonstrate nonimmigrant intent).
Waiver for Crimes Before the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act (IIRAIRA) INA 212(c)
This waiver was repealed on September 30, 1996 by IIRIRA, effective April 1, 1997. In INS v. St. Cyr, the U.S. Supreme Court held that a §212(c) waiver remains available in removal proceedings to a LPR who was eligible for the waiver at the time of his guilty plea entered before its repeal. INS v. St. Cyr, 533 U.S. 289, 326 (2001).
Basic Eligibility Requirements for a §212(c) Waiver:
1. LPR with a lawful domicile for at least 7 years; — 7 years of lawful domicile continued to accrue during exclusion and deportation proceedings until a final order was entered by an Immigration Judge (IJ) or the Bureau of Immigration Affairs (BIA).
2. Not excludable under former INA sections addressing national security and international child abduction.
3. For convictions entered between 11/30/1990 and 9/30/1996, the LPR has not served more than 5 years imprisonment for one or more aggravated felony offenses.
INA § 245(i) Waiver – Adjustment of Status
Statute §245(i) allows certain persons, (1) who have an immigrant visa immediately available but (2) who entered without inspection or otherwise violated their status and thus are ineligible to apply for adjustment of status in the United States, to apply if they pay a $1,000 penalty. The LIFE Act temporarily extends the ability to preserve eligibility for this provision of law until April 30, 2001. Use of Section 245(i) adjustment of status previously was limited to eligible individuals who were the beneficiary of a visa petition or labor certification application filed on or before January 14, 1998.
There is a $1000 penalty in addition to fees for adjustment application.
Exception – children under 17 and certain beneficiaries under Immigration Reform and Control Act.
Only applies to those grandfathered in – applicant must be a beneficiary of with a visa petition or employment based filed on or before April 30, 2001 and had to be approvable when filed.
To be approvable when filed, it must be:
(1) properly filed;
(2) meritorious in fact; and
(3) It is properly filed= as long as the fees were paid, even if denied later, as long
as petition was not frivolous;
It’s OK if it’s later denied, revoked or withdrawn, 8 CFR §245.10(a).
There must be physical presence in the US by December 21, 2000 (unless an underlying IV petition was filed on or before January 14, 1998). This does not waive any other grounds of inadmissibility.
Statute §254(1) attaches to the beneficiary not to the petition. Therefore, spouses and children who could demonstrate that a relationship with primary beneficiary of visa petition existed on or before April 30, 2001 are also grandfathered in, even if the relationship later changes, such as through divorce.
Child Sex Offenders as Petitioners
The Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006 (AWA) – amended immigration laws to protect children from sexual exploitation, by preventing sex offenders from petitioning for beneficiaries who might face harm due to petitioner’s criminal record.
The AWA prohibits USC or LPRs convicted of specified offenses against minors from filing an immigrant visa petition, unless USCIS determines that s/he poses no risk to beneficiary. You have to prove no risk “beyond a reasonable doubt.”
Determination Under AWA
Every risk determination is subject to judicial review – so USCIS makes the FINAL decision – continues to be a subject of federal litigation. It is very difficult to obtain a waiver if the violation qualifies under the AWA.
Unlawful Presence and Provisional Waivers 212(d)(3)
There are 2 unlawful presence bars – the 3-year and 10-year bar. Individuals who are unlawfully present in US for more than 180 days, but less than 1 year – are subject to 3- year bar upon exit. Individuals unlawfully present for one year or more are subject to 10- year bar upon exit.
This usually becomes an issue for individuals who are eligible to adjust, but ineligible to adjust while within the US (those who EWI or are not immediate relatives) – thus they have to go through consular processing – however bars are triggered upon exit.
I-601, Application for Waiver of Grounds of Inadmissibility
I-601 – must apply for I-601 waiver abroad – can only apply for this waiver after going to consular interview and being denied for unlawful presence grounds. The applicant must stay outside the US until the waiver is decided and approved. The applicant is then notified by consulate of second interview.
I-601A, Application for Provisional Unlawful Presence Waiver
I-601A – Must apply for I-601A waiver prior to departing the US. The waiver only applies to intending immigrants who (1) have a spouse or parent who is a USC or LPR and can be considered a qualifying relative and (2) can prove extreme hardship to that qualifying relative.
The foreign national must meet certain criteria: (1) be physically present in US, (2) be at least 17 years old, (3) be beneficiary of approved petition, (4) have a pending immigrant visa case, and (5) believe s/he is or will be inadmissible only for a period of unlawful presence in the US.
Agencies that Deem a Foreign National Inadmissible or Deportable
- US Consulates
- Enforcement Agencies- Customs and Border Protection and Immigration and Customs Enforcement
- Executive Office for Immigration Review
- BIA and Court System
3. Criminal Waivers
VAWA and Victims of Crimes and Trafficking
• Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
• Deferred Action Against Children Act (DACA)
• Central American Minors (CAM) Refugee and Parole Program
VAWA and Relief for Victims of Crime and Trafficking
• Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) (I-360 Vs. I-751)
U-Visa
Grants status to non-immigrant/undocumented victims of crimes who have suffered substantial mental or physical abuse. Who is Eligible?
- The applicant must have suffered substantial physical or mental abuse as a result of having been a victim of certain criminal activity described in INA section 1O1(a)(15)(U)(iii)
- The victim had been helpful, is being helpful, or is likely to be helpful in the investigation or prosecution of crime.
- The victim must contain information in regards to the criminal activity.
- The criminal activity violates U.S. Law or occurred in the United States.
Congress created the U nonimmigrant visa with the passage of the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act (including the Battered Immigrant Women’s Protection Act) in October of 2000. The legislation was intended to strengthen the ability of law enforcement agencies to investigate and prosecute cases of domestic violence, sexual assault, trafficking of aliens and other crimes while, at the same time, offer protection to victims of such crimes. The legislation also helps law enforcement agencies to better serve victims of crimes. The purpose of the U-visa is to give victims of certain crimes temporary legal status and work eligibility in the United States for up to 4 years. The U nonimmigrant status (U-visa) is set aside for victims of crimes who have suffered substantial mental or physical abuse and are willing to assist law enforcement and government officials in the investigation or prosecution of the criminal activity. All petitions must include information on how the victim can assist government officials in learning more about the crime including investigation and/or prosecution of the individual(s) that committed the crime. The victim must also be willing to work with local law enforcement. The crime must have occurred in the United States or in a U.S. territory, or violated U.S. law.
U- Visa – I-918 and Supporting Documentation
- G-28 Form – to be prepared by Attorney
- I-918 Form Application- to be prepared by Attorney
- G-325A Form, Biographic Information – to be prepared by Attorney after Client gives a handwritten/typed and filled out copy of 325A back to this office.
- Birth Certificate
- Translation of Birth Certificate
- Biographic Page of Passport
- Two (2) Passport-style Photographs
Evidence of Victimization/Criminal Act – Evidence Applicant Suffered
- Substantial Physical Harm
- Victim Statement of Client
- Original I-918 Supplement B
- County Sherriff’s Office Incident Report about the crime
- Court Records of the trial against the criminal defendant.
- Emergency Protective Order- if there was one
- Arrest Report for the Defendant/Perpetrator (person who committed the crime)
- Medical Records- if harm incurred as a result of being a victim of a criminal activity
- Headaches and Post-Concussion Syndrome (Adult)- if any
- Letter from ____ at the Victim’s Witness-VW of ____ county, dated ________
- How VW was involved in the criminal case for which Client has certification i.e. I-918B. the letter can state/explain what type of harm did client suffer: i.e. if Client got Victim compensation or Restitution.
- Letter from _____ MFT dated ________
- __MFT_ verifies that Client has been receiving individual therapy services from the ____. Client meets with MFT on a weekly/monthly basis for 50 minutes sessions. Client came to the MFT because she was feeling depressed, tense, panic, tired, crying and having trouble with memory and concentration due to becoming a victim of the crime.
- Letter Case Management Program Supervisor/priest/community leader, dated ___________
- ____ verifies that Client participates in enrichment activities at___/Resource Center. For example, it can state that Client shares community resources with her peers and also shares arts and crafts activities.
- Did client suffer: i.e. if Client got Victim compensation or Restitution.
- I-192 Application- to be prepared by Attorney
- Declaration of client in Support of the I-192– to be prepared by Attorney
- Letter of Support for Client- stating that client is a productive member of society, law- abiding citizen and has substantial ties in community.
- By friends
- By employer
- By clerics/priests/imams/pundits/community leaders.
- By other non-profits where client may have volunteered in the past
T-Visa
An immigrant is eligible for T nonimmigrant status where the immigrant:
1) is or has been a victim of a severe form of trafficking in persons;
2) is physically present in the United States on account of such trafficking;
3) has complied with any reasonable request for assistance in the investigation of acts of trafficking; and
4) would suffer extreme hardship involving unusual and severe harm upon removal. INA § 101(a)(15)(T)(as amended); 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(T).
Trafficking Defined
Statute § 103(8) of the Trafficking Act defines “severe forms of trafficking in persons” as:
(A) sex trafficking[1] in which a commercial sex act is induced by force, fraud, or coercion, or in which the person induced to perform such an act has not attained 18 years of age; or
(B) the recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for labor or services, through the use of force, fraud, or coercion for the purpose of subjection to involuntary servitude, peonage, debt bondage, or slavery.
Coercion includes:
Threats of serious harm to or physical restraint against any person; any scheme, plan, or pattern intended to cause a person to believe that failure to perform an act would result in serious harm to or physical restraint against any person; or the abuse or threatened abuse of the legal process. (8 C.F.R. § 214.11(a))
Abuse of the legal process means:
The use or threatened use of a law or legal process, whether administrative, civil, or criminal, in any manner or for any purpose for which the law was not designed, in order to exert pressure on another person to cause that person to take some action or refrain from taking some action. (8 U.S.C. § 1589(c)(1))
Involuntary servitude, therefore, “encompasses those cases in which the defendant holds the victim in servitude by . . . legal coercion. ”United States v. Kozminski, 487 U.S. 931, 952 (1988). Not only do threats of reporting to law enforcement constitute abuse of the legal process, it is undisputed that “threats of deportation constitute a condition of servitude induced through abuse of the legal process.” Id. Seealso Nunang-Tanedo v. East Baton Rouge Parish School Bd., 790 F.Supp.2d 1134, 1146 (C.D. Cal. 2011); U.S. v. Calimlim, 538, F.3d 706, 713 (7th Cir. 2008) (finding that “warnings” that a domestic servant would be deported because of lack of immigration process constitute “an abuse of the legal process”); U.S. v. Garcia, 2003 Lexis 22088, at 4 (W.D.N.Y.2003) (holding that “threats of deportation” establish a “prima facie showing of involuntary servitude”).
T-Visa Application Requirements, With Examples
Victim is physically present in the United States on account of his/her trafficking.(See INA § 101(a)(15)(T)(i)(II)(as amended); 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(T)(i)(II)).
Example: XXXX’s trafficker fraudulently recruited him to come to the United States, promising him a good job working in the avocado fields. Once in the United States, his trafficker forced XXXX to work against his will, subjecting him to dangerous working conditions, repeated threats, and severe coercion.
Victim is physically present in the United States on account of his/her trafficking. (See INA § 101(a)(15)(T)(i)(II)(as amended); 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(T)(i)(II)).
Example: XXXX would suffer “extreme hardship involving unusual and severe harm upon removal” to Mexico. See INA § 101(a)(15)(T)(i)(IV)(as amended); 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(T)(i)(IV). As a result of these dangers, XXXX must stay in the United States to avoid retaliation and re-trafficking in Mexico, receive critical social services to recover from his trafficking, and to receive restitution for his injuries.
For one thing, XXXX faces a high probability of retaliation at the hands of his trafficker in Mexico. (See 8 C.F.R. 245.23(f); 8 C.F.R. 214.11(i)(1)(vii).) XXXX’s trafficker knows where XXXX and his family live in Mexico and recruited him from his small town. He repeatedly threatened XXXX not to speak to law enforcement, and he is furious with XXXX and the other workers for cooperating with law enforcement. Moreover, XXXX’s trafficker has power and influence in Mexico. XXXX is terrified that his trafficker will harm him or his family if XXXX returns. High levels of corruption and impunity in Mexico mean that XXXX’s trafficker will be able to use his wealth and influence to harm XXXX and that the Mexican authorities will be unable and unwilling to protect him from the trafficker’s abuse. See, .e.g., Exhibit S, U.S. Department of State, Mexico 2013 Human Rights Report (2014).
Victim has also cooperated with all reasonable requests for cooperation in the investigation of his trafficking. (See INA § 101(a)(15)(T)(i)(III)(as amended); 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(T)(i)(III)).
Example: Despite threats of retaliation from his traffickers, XXXX courageously reported his trafficking to the California Economic Development Department and the federal Department of Labor, meeting with EDD investigators while still in his trafficking situation, and he has been interviewed by them several times since his escape. XXXX has repeatedly informed law enforcement of his desire to continue to cooperate in their investigation and he has cooperated with all reasonable requests for assistance in the investigation into his trafficking.
Victim would suffer “extreme hardship involving unusual and severe harm upon removal” to home country
See INA § 101(a)(15)(T)(i)(IV)(as amended); 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(T)(i)(IV).
XXXX must stay in the United States to avoid retaliation and re-trafficking in Mexico, receive critical social services to recover from his trafficking, and to receive restitution for his injuries.
First, XXXX faces a high probability of retaliation at the hands of his trafficker in Mexico. See 8 C.F.R. 245.23(f); 8 C.F.R. 214.11(i)(1)(vii). XXXX’s trafficker knows where XXXX and his family live in Mexico and recruited him from his small town. He repeatedly threatened XXXX not to speak to law enforcement, and he is furious with XXXX and the other workers for cooperating with law enforcement. Moreover, XXXX’s trafficker has power and influence in Mexico. XXXX is terrified that his trafficker will harm him or his family if XXXX returns. High levels of corruption and impunity in Mexico mean that XXXX’s trafficker will be able to use his wealth and influence to harm XXXX and that the Mexican authorities will be unable and unwilling to protect him from the trafficker’s abuse. (See, e.g., Exhibit S, U.S. Department of State, Mexico 2013 Human Rights Report (2014)).
T-Visa Adjustment of Status (AOS) Process
The victim must apply for AOS within the 4 years that T Visa is granted. The victim also needs to show that the applicant was continuously helpful with the investigation. If the victim suffers from inadmissibility, he or she would need to apply for a waiver (I-192).
T-Visa Vs. U-Visa
A U-visa and a T-visa both require certification. For a U-visa, the only grounds for inadmissibility are participation in Nazi persecution or genocide, or commission of acts of torture or extrajudicial killing. For the T-visa, you can apply for a waiver during the adjustment process. As for eligibility criteria, for a U-visa, you must not have unreasonably refused to assist law enforcement. Also, your presence just be justified on humanitarian grounds, to ensure family unity, or in the public interest. In contrast, for a T visa, you must have good moral character; you must have complied with reasonable requests for assistance from law enforcement, or would suffer extreme hardship involving unusual and severe harm if forced to leave.
[1] Section 103 (9) provides “[t]he term `sex trafficking’ means the recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for the purpose of a commercial sex act.”
T-Visa Vs. U-Visa
A U-visa and a T-visa both require certification. For a U-visa, the only grounds for inadmissibility are participation in Nazi persecution or genocide, or commission of acts of torture or extrajudicial killing. For the T-visa, you can apply for a waiver during the adjustment process. As for eligibility criteria, for a U-visa, you must not have unreasonably refused to assist law enforcement. Also, your presence just be justified on humanitarian grounds, to ensure family unity, or in the public interest. In contrast, for a T visa, you must have good moral character; you must have complied with reasonable requests for assistance from law enforcement, or would suffer extreme hardship involving unusual and severe harm if forced to leave.
Special Immigrant Juvenile Status
(SIJS) (INA § 101(a)(27)(j))
This classification was created to protect children who are abused or abandoned in the United States. According to the statute, to qualify for SIJ status, the child must be:
· Declared dependent in a juvenile court in the United States, and
· Legally committed or placed under the custody of an agency or an individual appointed by the State, and
· Such that reunification with one or both parents is not viable due to abuse, neglect, or abandonment, or a similar basis found under the State law.
Furthermore, it must also be ascertained that it is not in the best interest of the child to be returned to their home country.
The SIJS process contains two steps. The first step is to obtain a dependency court order from a juvenile court, a special court tailored to children. This step does not involve USCIS. The second step involves applying for SIJS status from USCIS, and can be done defensively (if the youth is in removal) or affirmatively. The process is slightly different in either case but, in both cases, involves filling out and submitting a Form I-360 Petition for Amerasian, Widow(er), or Special Immigrant to USCIS.
Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA)
The Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals was designed to address the needs of children of intact families brought to the United States. It originated as part of the 2001 Development, Relief, and Education for Minors or Dream Act but, since the Dream act ultimately was not enacted, was slightly modified so that it still provides some relief. Specifically, DACA provides an employment authorization document. It also allows youth to apply to travel using Form I-131 Application for Travel Document.
As of July 17, 2019, USCIS is not accepting requests from individuals who have never before been granted deferred action under DACA. Due to federal court orders on Jan. 9, 2018 and Feb. 13, 2018, USCIS has resumed accepting requests to renew a grant of deferred action under DACA.
You may request a renewal of DACA if you met the initial 2012 DACA guidelines and you:
- Did not depart the United States on or after Aug. 15, 2012, without advance parole;
- Have continuously resided in the United States since you submitted your most recent DACA request that was approved;
- Have not been convicted of a felony, a significant misdemeanor, or three or more other misdemeanors; and
- Do not otherwise pose a threat to national security or public safety.
DACA Requirements
You may request DACA if you:
- Were under the age of 31 as of June 15, 2012;
- Came to the United States before reaching your 16th birthday;
- Have continuously resided in the United States since June 15, 2007, up to the present time;
- Were physically present in the United States on June 15, 2012, and at the time of making your request for consideration of deferred action with USCIS;
- Had no lawful status on June 15, 2012;
- Are currently in school, have graduated or obtained a certificate of completion from high school, have obtained a general education development (GED) certificate, or are an honorably discharged veteran of the Coast Guard or Armed Forces of the United States; and
- Have not been convicted of a felony, significant misdemeanor, or three or more other misdemeanors, and do not otherwise pose a threat to national security or public safety.
Central American Minors Refugee Program (CAM)
The Central American Minors Refugee Program (CAM program) was established in 2014 to provide certain minors in El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras the opportunity to be considered, while still in their home country, for refugee resettlement in the United States. Individuals who were determined to be ineligible for refugee status were then considered by USCIS for the possibility of entering the United States under parole. The parole portion of the CAM program was terminated in August 2017.
To be eligible, a child must:
- Be a national of El Salvador, Guatemala, or Honduras, even if the parent is not
- Be residing in his or her country of nationality
- Be a biological, adopted or stepchild of a qualifying parent, and
- Be unmarried and under 21 years of age.
On Nov. 9, 2017, the Department of State stopped accepting new applications for the Central American Minors (CAM) refugee program. USCIS stopped interviewing CAM cases on Jan. 31, 2018.
Immigration Law
Moving or travelling to United States can be challenging and time consuming. Immigrants deal with many logistical costs and personal, professional and emotional hurdles in order to migrate to U.S.
Millions of immigrants enter the U.S.A. every year for a variety of reasons. Some enter as immigrants with intent to stay while others enter the U.S. on as non-immigrants such as foreign students. Yet many others enter the U.S. as professionals to establish a business or with the intent to practice their profession.
Immigration Law is complex as the numerous visa categories are contained in different statutory codes, subject to different legislation, documentation and fees requirement. Crimmigration Inc. is dedicated to help you determine which type of immigration relief and category you might be eligible for and to facilitate your way through the process.
External Links & Resources
US Citizenship and Immigration Services
Check your case status
Check filing fees
Find Medical Doctor (Civil Surgeon)
USCIS Forms
USCIS Laws and Guides
USCIS Resources
National processing trends
U.S. Department of State (DOS)
Embassy and Consulate Informations
Visa Services
Visa Bulletin
Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)
US Department of Labor (DOL)
Employment and training
Labour Certification
Prevailing wage information